Top Stories

The Michigan Messenger going forward

By Staff Report | 11.16.11

I am writing today to announce the closure of the Michigan Messenger. After four years of operation in Michigan, the board of the American Independent News Network, has decided to shift publication of its news into a single site, The American Independent at Americanindependent.com. This is part of a shift in strategy, towards new forms [...]

Colorado-based abstinence program provided false and misleading information to Michigan students

HIV-AIDS-small
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.16.11

An abstinence-only presentation provided to numerous school districts in Calhoun and Eaton Counties in October of this year provided false and misleading information to students about HIV, experts allege.

Class action lawsuit filed against MERS over unpaid taxes

foreclosure
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.15.11

Two county registers of deeds filed a class action lawsuit Monday on behalf of Michigan’s 83 counties alleging that the Mortgage Electronic Registration Services owes millions of dollars in property title transfer taxes.

Schuette fights important mercury regulations

epa_logo
By Eartha Jane Melzer | 11.14.11

Despite evidence of the impact of mercury on children and public health, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette last month joined with 24 other state attorneys general in filing a lawsuit to scuttle new EPA regulations that would reduce mercury emissions from power plants.

Stupak denies knowledge of connections to mysterious ‘C Street’ house he lives in

By Ed Brayton | 07.23.09 | 3:26 pm

Despite weeks of media attention paid to the now-infamous “C Street” house owned by The Family, a secretive Christian group, U.S. Rep. Bart Stupak — who lives at the house near the U.S. Capitol — denied any knowledge of the nature of the mysterious Washington, D.C., rowhouse and any involvement with the organization that owns it and uses as a seat of influence on Capitol Hill.

U.S. Rep. Bart Stupak (Creative Commons photo by Brian Rendel via Flickr)

U.S. Rep. Bart Stupak (Creative Commons photo by Brian Rendel via Flickr)

During a conference call with reporters Thursday morning, Michigan Messenger asked Stupak, a Menominee Democrat, about the house where he has lived for many years and his connections to the shadowy organization that owns it. The longtime Upper Peninsula legislator claimed to have “no affiliation” with the group, which is known as The Family or The Fellowship.

“I don’t belong to any such group,” Stupak said. “I rent a room at a house in ‘C Street.’ I do not belong to any such group. I don’t know what you’re talking about, [The] Family and all this other stuff.”

The C Street house, a former convent, is still listed on official tax documents as a church but it functions largely as a boarding house, with six to eight members of the U.S. House and Senate living there at any given time. Current residents include Stupak, Rep. Zach Wamp (R-Tenn.), Sen. Tom Coburn (R-Okla.), Rep. Mike Doyle (D-Pa.) and Sen. John Ensign (R-Nev.), and Rep. Heath Shuler (D-N.C.).

The house has become the focus of much attention after the public admissions of adultery by Ensign and Gov. Mark Sanford of South Carolina. It has been widely reported that Coburn and other residents of the house knew of Ensign’s affair long before it became public and helped him negotiate his way through it. Sanford likewise mentioned in the press conference where he admitted his infidelity that he had been receiving spiritual counseling at the C Street house.

When asked if there were any ethical concerns created by living in a house inaccurately listed as a church in order to evade property taxes, Stupak replied: “I don’t own the building, I don’t know how the landlord has it listed. I pay rent for a room. I sleep there. I have a room.”

Jeff Sharlet, contributing editor at Harper’s magazine and the author of “The Family: The Secret Fundamentalism at the Heart of American Power,” lived for a time at Ivanwald, another boarding house owned by the group in Arlington, Va., this one for younger men without political power.

Sharlet said that Stupak’s denial of any knowledge of The Family or its activities is false. “When I lived with The Family at Ivanwald, a house for younger men being groomed for leadership, I was told that Stupak was a regular visitor to the Cedars,” Sharlet said. The Cedars is yet another compound owned by The Family, one that hosts weekly prayer events led by former Reagan-era Attorney General Ed Meese.

Sharlet said that Stupak had much greater involvement with the group than he is admitting, noting that the congressman was “a Family-assigned mentor to one of my brothers at Ivanwald.” That Ivanwald resident, Sharlet said, “regularly left for what he and others described as mentoring sessions.”

Another reason to doubt Stupak’s denials, Sharlet said, is that members of the organization and those who live at the C Street house are sworn to secrecy about what goes on there, as fellow resident Zach Wamp admitted to the Knoxville News in the wake of the recent scandals. That makes such denials less credible, Sharlet said.

“The bottom line here is that Stupak is either being dishonest or confessing dangerous ignorance,” Sharlet said. “The house’s function has been public knowledge since the [Associated Press] wrote about it 7 years ago. Multiple mainstream media outlets have reported on the house’s role as in effect, a lobby in all but name, led by a man who is on video and audio record citing the leadership lessons of Hitler, Stalin, and Mao.”

Sharlet’s book describes The Family as a kind of shadow multi-national government, operating in secret through small prayer groups called “cells” and modeled after the organization of mafia and terrorist groups. Doug Coe, the leader of the group, frequently refers to the leadership lessons of Hitler and the example of the mafia as a model for how the group operates.

How far-reaching is The Family’s influence? David Kuo, a high-ranking official in the Bush administration who oversaw the White House’s office of faith-based initiatives, wrote in a recent book: “The Fellowship’s reach into governments around the world is almost impossible to overstate or even grasp.”

When contacted for a reaction to Sharlet’s accusations and for follow-up questions about his involvement in the organization and his residency at C Street, Stupak’s spokesman, Nick Choate, replied: “The congressman will not have any further comment on the matter.”

Correction: This article originally listed Rep. Joseph Pitts of Pennsylvania as a resident of the C street house, which has been widely reported elsewhere. But we have been informed by his spokesperson that the congressman does not reside at the C street house, nor has he ever resided there. We apologize for the error.

Comments

  • http://notionscapital.com Mike_Licht

    The Congressional Recess is coming. Don't forget to sign up for the Fellowship's Vacation Bible School.

    See:

    http://notionscapital.wordpress.com/2009/07/22/…

  • Michael_Heath

    It'd be great to see the media outlets in Rep. Stupak's district leverage Mr. Brayton's efforts here and follow-up with their own stories.

  • dsincal

    Of course he doesn't know about it – he's not a far right republican and he's not going to be asked to join their little cult.

    • mznomer

      Bart Stupak is a fundamentalist. Examine his voting record. For example, his continued sponsorship of uncounted H-2(b) visas for non-skilled immigrant labor (House Bills #1136 & 1934) reflect the century-old position of this “christian” group to oppose labor, organized & other, as the work of Satan.

      His advocacy of non-competitive labor importation–especially at this time of record MI unemployment—suggests he is responding to some “higher power” & not the obvious needs of the voters in MI's First District.

      BS likes to boast about his personal history as a former MSP trooper. So, if he's “unaware” of what going on around him, one has to wonder that which Mr. Stupak is aware.

      • joeelden

        I didn't know this about him. Perhaps time to research a little more. Thanks for the post.

    • ebrayton

      This is not a conventional religious right group. The group is about 80% Republicans and 20% Democrats. Stupak is hardly the only Democrat involved with them. Others include Kent Conrad and Ben Nelson. The Family is, quite intentionally, not tied to a political party the way groups like Focus on the Family or the Christian Coalition are. Their goals are much bigger and transcend party.

      • AlwaysOptimistic

        Senator Bill Nelson is a member. Also, a democrat.

        This group believes in no social programs and the complete deregulation of the markets. Bills in Congress have been sponsored by members of this group for decades, including the Silk Road Act which funneled millions of our tax dollars to Central Asian dictators with the expressed effort to open these countries to free markets. Sen. Brownback, member of this group, said once you did this….It would stop Islam and open these countries to the Bible….

        Can you say Crusades?

        • NonCompassionateLiberal

          Hillary Clinton is also a member.

          • ebrayton

            Hillary is not a member, she's a “friend.” The group is very conscious of distinguishing between members and friends (though there is no official membership roll, those within the group make a clear distinction). A member is someone who actually is assigned to a prayer group or “cell.” A friend is someone who takes part in a prayer session or group meeting here or there but isn't really actively involved. They consider Hillary Clinton and Al Gore to be friends; Stupak, on the other hand, is a member, as is Ben Nelson.

          • NonCompassionateLiberal

            You're right. I should have written that she was “involved.” Bill Maher was right when he said that the Democrats are now the “new Republicans.” When James Carville married Mary Matalin was when it started to look scary, and now it's just scarier.

          • feuclair

            Hillary Clinton was a member. This was thoroughly researched during the Democratic primary.
            I would hate to think she retains ties with this group.

          • bgcarb

            Show me proof that Hillary Clinton was an active member living there and not just someone who participated in prayer groups years ago. I never trust the slurs against Hillary as they are most often unsubstantiated. Unless you can back it up, then I think it is just more propaganda.

          • feuclair

            http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2007/09/hil…

            http://www.thenation.com/doc/20080331/ehrenreich
            There's more if you care to look.
            Of course she didn't live there. There was a period when her ties with them were close and constant.

          • bgcarb

            Thanks for taking the time to provide the links. The articles state she was a constant in a prayer group with wives of Polss. I'm thinking that was probably a world of difference compared to the politics/beliefs of “the family” that has lived there in the past couple years, though.

    • roark33

      Michigan voters should take notice of this man's lies. Yes…I really believe he lived at C Street and didn't participate in the prayer meetings. I

      And it's not about being a Republican or Democrat. It's about who's influencing their decisions. Obviously, this group doesn't represent the views of mainstream America. The most shocked people should be his constituents, who I'm sure did not know he lived there. I'm sure they would not have voted for him if they did.

    • feuclair

      You don't know Rep. Stupak, do you?
      I suggest you spend a little time with him at fund raisers et al. You will find him quite odd and a bit of a cold fish. This does not make him evil or an unqualified legislator. He has been known as a member of The Fellowship for years.
      I do not agree with many of his positions and I certainly am not comfortable being represented by someone who pals around with James Imhoffe.
      There you have it.

      • dsincal

        Don't know him, should have done some research before spouting!

        • bigmikeh1965

          stupak would have to be a democrat to run in that area, the UP is almost all Democrat. as for his personality, he suffered a family tragedy about 10 years ago that would have left lasting pain.

          • bgcarb

            Yes his family did have a horrible tragedy. He's odd in that he isn't as sophisticated as some pols are, but I think there is more to this C Street thing. How nice that he is able to get cheap rent because his building is registered as a church. I know a lot of apartment buildings that would love that tax break.

          • feuclair

            He was the same before the family tragedy. I don't believe there's cause and effect there at all.

  • nellpost

    I think he needs to re-think his answers. Frankly.

  • AlwaysOptimistic

    Members of both political parties have been members of The Family for decades. This group's agenda is to “see that God's sovereignty is extended to every aspect of governance; to see a complete deregulation of the markets; and to end all social programs.

    http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?st…

    Wake up America to the ambitions of this secret group. Doug Coe says there needs to be complete deregulation of the markets so “God can choose who is to be wealthy”.

    Scary, scary group!

  • tcatherine

    Some of this kind of information was available on the web when everyone was scrambling to figure out why Palin was selected as a vice presidential candidate. The very same kind of agenda was described for the organizations she was affiliated with which may explain why such a know-nothing would even be considered. After she won the election for governor there was footage of a conference she attended and the intro given before she spoke indicated that she was part of a larger agenda to place fundamentalist people in into strategic positions. One of the key patterns of complaints against her has been putting questionable people into positions of power that were affiliated with her church. Also when she gave her resignation announcement she mentioned a higher calling. No one really could determine what she meant by that but I think at least in her mind she is still trying to further the aims of her brand of Christian fundamentalist takeover. By the way I am a Christian and appalled by all of this.

  • Pitt

    Talk about pod people. The outing has begun.

    http://www.light-to-dark.com/The_Family.html

  • bgcarb

    Show me proof that Hillary Clinton was an active member living there and not just someone who participated in prayer groups years ago. I never trust the slurs against Hillary as they are most often unsubstantiated. Unless you can back it up, then I think it is just more propaganda.

  • bgcarb

    Yes his family did have a horrible tragedy. He's odd in that he isn't as sophisticated as some pols are, but I think there is more to this C Street thing. How nice that he is able to get cheap rent because his building is registered as a church. I know a lot of apartment buildings that would love that tax break.

  • vince2009

    http://jonathanturley.org/2009/06/26/stimulatin…

    November 16, 2009 at 8:55 am

    Here is some great news. I reported above, June 26, 2009 at 10:09 am, that the religious retreat on Capitol Hill was nothing but a tax dodge: “The property is Tax Type E1, Religious. It is tax exempt. No tax payments are shown. The Members live in a tax-free property. Most of those who live in the District have to pay property taxes, or pay rent to landlords who pay property taxes. These Senators and Representatives say some prayers in the dining room, claim their flophouse as a church, convent or monastery, and pay sub-market rent for their rooms. They are sponging off the taxpayers of the District, and will not even vote to give them representation in Congress.

    ”This does not even sink to the level of hypocrisy. It is pure, simple, unadulterated, unmitigated gall.”

    So the right-wing residential “church” on Capitol Hill at 133 E St SE, where Mark Sanford and John Ensign mulled over their respective adulteries, used to be exempt from property tax as a religious property.

    Well, at least one complaint just happened to be filed a few months ago, by some anonymous citizen who will remain nameless “”wink, wink,” with the taxpayer hotline at the DC tax office.

    The property has now been reclassified as residential, with a taxable assessment of $1,834,500.

    They paid their property tax on October 21, 2009, in the amount of $1,714.70.

    https://www.taxpayerservicecenter.com/RP_Search…

    (Just plug in the address 133 C St SE, then click on “square/lot” in upper left, then click on “view payments” in lower right. It is all there).

    Owner Name: YOUTH WITH A MISSION WASHINGTON DC INC C ST CENTER
    Tax Class: 001 – Residential.

  • lynnhyattbrown

    I live in Michigan's 1st District – and this is NOT a Democratic area by a long shot! It is a minor miracle that we have a Dem US Rep, and that is only because Stupak is pretty conservative.

    As for support of seasonal H-2(b) visas: That is about Mackinac Island, a beautiful summer resort island area. We need to import workers for the summer. Our family businesses are in critical need of summer workers – college students won't do the work, auto workers won't, and there is not enough local population to fill all the need.

    It seems counter-intuitive with the unemployment in Michigan, but our situation is pretty dire. Every season we all struggle to open our doors because we do not have enough workers. Before 9/11 many hospitality workers came from winter resort areas, Jamaica, etc. Now they are not allowed and we are all going to go down if we don't get some of them back!!

    As much as I love a good conspiracy, Stupak is trying to help real people and their businesses in our District – not some nutty group!

    • bindistrict1

      I live in the first district as well, and there are so many unemployed here that would love to take those summer jobs on Mackinac Island or anywhere else, it ain't even funny.

      The reason you seasonal business owners can't get workers is because you don't want to pay them squat, offer no benefits, lay them off before they can work up unemployment benefits to get them through the winter again, and therefore make it impossible for them to make a living with you if they try.

      They don't have the option to go back to Jamaica when the season's over to make beds and serve drinks to the snow birds and jet set. They've got homes and families right here in the first district to try to support through some tough winters. Their bills and mortgages and rent payments and need to put food on the table doesn't stop just because the season's over and the business owners are settled in nice and cozy and living off the season's profits.

      Stupak better start thinking about THOSE people for a change, and he needs to stop voting with his crucifix and his prayer beads and his bronze-age mentality towards social issues, and get with the program of serving THE PEOPLE of his district. I can tell you right now that I'm ready to do everything I can to influence others to vote him right the heck out of office, especially after this latest fiasco of the “Stupak amendment” that was like shooting a torpedo into the health care negotiations.

      A lot of people I've talked to are already appalled at ol' Bart for some of his bone-head moves up there on the Hill, and this latest one got WAY too much negative attention to easily forget.

      And I'll tell you something else: After listening to him on the first district conference calls, there's no doubt in my mind that he's a theistic nut-job who needs a new employment path. I'm thinking making beds and serving drinks on Mackinac Island would be a good career move for him.

      • lynnhyattbrown

        I agree, Stupack is on the wrong track.

        And you are wrong about working on Mackinac Island.

        People/owners here work really hard and do their best for their employees and for their business.  If you need extra help for 6 weeks in the middle of the summer, and you pay really well for that help – what more can you do?  Its the nature of the beast.

        Our company does have health insurance, zero co-pay actually, and many year-round employees.  Many of our workers do support their families with the pay the earn here.  We have not taken any profits form the company for a decade, beyond a pay check, so there is no settling in 'nice and cozy'.  It would be nice though.

        Best,
        Lynn

  • EagleNE1

    It seems to me that there are other “powers that be” trying to smudge my respected representative's reputation. Here is not where you will find how Bart Stupak has
    helped the Michigan's First District. Please take a minute and go to http://www.house.gov/stupak and see the good he has done for us. Here are a few things for example: 170 jobs created or retained in Marquette, Alger, and Delta Counties for installation of broadband Internet services…he has fought to get the outlying peoples connected. He has fought to protect the Great Lakes. Key reforms in the House health reform bill are these: Prohibit insurance companies from discriminating against pre-existing conditions; Eliminate lifetime caps on benefits; allow young people up to age 27 to remain on their parents policy; Prohibits taxpayer-funded health care for illegal immigrants, etc. etc. etc. Please people, understand that Bart Stupak is for you. I have been following his work for us for years and find that he is one of the most honest and trusted of all the politicians. He cannot be bought. The insurance companies hate him because he is fighting for you. But you are listening to the lies contained in this unfortunate article. I believe Bart because he has a history of telling the truth. I do not believe your fiction. A lot of us do not want our tax dollars to fund abortions because it is our money and we believe abortion is wrong. Woman still have the freedom to obtain abortions. This does not make us the devil…as you seem to imply.

  • helensatmary

    Sounds like a left wing conspiracy theory to me. They do not like the idea that he would prevent babies from abortion. Obama's favorite objective. God bless him for his stand against abortion.

  • mikerodriquez

    After reading all these post and understanding the conspiratorial nature of their underlying premises I've come to the conclusion that liberalism is a mental disorder.

    Fellowship Foundation, also known as the prayer breakfast groups, is an international organization founded in 1935 by Dr. Abraham Vereide in Seattle, Washington and incorporated in the central United States city of Chicago. Its participation includes a vast array of high ranking government officials, corporate executives, heads of religious and humanitarian aid organizations, and ambassadors, spanning the globe. It has been described as one of the most well-connected ministries in the US.

    The core purpose of this group is to provide a fellowship forum for decision makers to share in Bible Studies, prayer meetings, worship experiences and to experience spiritual affirmation and support. In Newsweek, Lisa Miller writes that the common love for the teachings of Jesus binds this group together and all approaches to understanding him are acceptable.

  • dougfear1

    i have a hard time with stupak saying he don't know anything about c house since he has lived there for some time. further information about stupak and his living arangement at the c house should brought forth and investigated. also his connection to the member owners! i don't understand why he refuses to believe no government money will pay for abortians! i wonder if the c house is telling him to kill health reform???

  • dougfear1

    i have a hard time with stupak saying he don't know anything about c house since he has lived there for some time. further information about stupak and his living arangement at the c house should brought forth and investigated. also his connection to the member owners! i don't understand why he refuses to believe no government money will pay for abortians! i wonder if the c house is telling him to kill health reform???