Michigan Senator Debbie Stabenow voted today with a majority of senators to protect telecommunications companies against civil lawsuits, defeating Amendment 3907. Commonly referred to as the “Dodd Amendment”, this legislation would have struck down provisions in the FISA Amendments Act of 2007 granting immunity from civil liability to electronic communication service providers for domestic spying via warrantless wiretaps on Americans. The wiretaps were requested by the Bush Administration.
Michigan’s senior senator, Carl Levin voted with the minority to support the amendment.
Stabenow’s vote is at odds with her recent vote against a bill endorsing warrantless wiretapping, introduced by Sen. Mitch McConnell (R-Kentucky). Stabenow said in a recent letter, “I believe Congress has a responsibility to protect the American people, but like you, I understand that some of these measures may threaten certain civil liberties. In the war on terrorism, it is vital to ensure that we do not sacrifice the very liberties we are fighting to protect.”
When contacted by phone, Stabenow’s office was unable to provide a rationale for her position on today’s vote, offering instead to have the senator respond by letter sometime in the future.