Professors from a dozen public universities in Michigan are calling on the governor and the Department of Natural Resources to consider ethical reasons to oppose plans for a nickel-sulfide mine on public land in the Upper Peninsula.
On Dec. 14, the Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) approved a permit for a Kennecott Eagle Minerals Company (a Rio Tinto subsidiary) nickel-mining operation in the Yellow Dog Plains outside Marquette. In a letter announcing the approval, the DEQ said that it could only consider technical matters in making the decision. But approval from the Department of Natural Resources (DNR) is also required.
The mine proposal has inspired widespread opposition on environmental grounds. Sulfide mines are a leading cause of water pollution, according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, because they expose minerals that react with air and water and create acid mine drainage.
The group of 40 professors — mostly biologists, ecologists and philosophers — told the governor and the DNR that environmental costs, though uncertain, should not be downplayed in decision-making.
Continued -“When a mine is built on state land for a private, commercial use, it needs a permit, and those decisions have always been discretionary — not based on technical matters but on what is appropriate,” said John Vucetich, assistant professor of animal ecology at Michigan Technological University. “It is about how ought we to use our resources