I am writing today to announce the closure of the Michigan Messenger. After four years of operation in Michigan, the board of the American Independent News Network, has decided to shift publication of its news into a single site, The American Independent at Americanindependent.com. This is part of a shift in strategy, towards new forms [...]
An abstinence-only presentation provided to numerous school districts in Calhoun and Eaton Counties in October of this year provided false and misleading information to students about HIV, experts allege.
Two county registers of deeds filed a class action lawsuit Monday on behalf of Michigan’s 83 counties alleging that the Mortgage Electronic Registration Services owes millions of dollars in property title transfer taxes.
Despite evidence of the impact of mercury on children and public health, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette last month joined with 24 other state attorneys general in filing a lawsuit to scuttle new EPA regulations that would reduce mercury emissions from power plants.
Benton Harbor Emergency Manager Joe Harris said last night that 90 percent of the local citizens believe that he is the “angel of common sense” though he acknowledged that no poll has been taken.
Earlier this month Harris used new powers granted under Public Act 4 — the Emergency Manager law — to remove all decision making power from Benton Harbor’s elected officials.
“They were effectively … fired by the state legislature,” Harris told
Fox 2 News. “… Public Act 4 of 2011 stripped all local government legislators and the mayors and the city officials of the power that they once had. The order that I issued a couple weeks ago simply reiterated the fact that these individuals no longer had the authority that they once had.”
Harris, who formerly served as Chief Financial Officer and as Auditor General for the city of Detroit, said that it is conceivable that he will terminate contracts for public workers in Benton Harbor and he said that Mayor Bing will not be able to address Detroit’s financial problems without authority to change the terms of collective bargaining agreements.
Sec. 19. (1) An emergency manager may take 1 or more of the following additional actions with respect to a local
government which is in receivership, notwithstanding any charter provision to the contrary: …
(j) Reject, modify, or terminate 1 or more terms and conditions of an existing contract.
—–
Contrast that language with the following sub-section, which reads (in pertinent part):
—-
(k) After meeting and conferring with the appropriate bargaining representative and, if in the emergency
manager’s sole discretion and judgment, a prompt and satisfactory resolution is unlikely to be obtained, reject,
modify, or terminate 1 or more terms and conditions of an existing collective bargaining agreement.
—-
The legislature is presumed to understand the terms it uses, and to have selected its terms carefully; thus, when it says “contract” in subsection j, but “collective bargaining agreement” in subsection k, rest assured, it means two very different things.
Among the other powers granted them recently, the EFMs now have the power to disincorporate a township. The Act makes no distinction between “land” or “legal” townships (also called “survey townships” or “Congressional townships”), on the one hand, and “political” townships (akin to a city, village, etc.), on the other – it just says “township”. If you own real estate in Michigan (or any Northwest Ordinance state – MI, WI, OH, IN, IL), pull out your deed or mortgage, and read the legal description of the land. You’ll see it’s described in terms of sections of ranges and TOWNSHIPS. Those are “land” or “legal” townships. The Township of Benton Harbor, which recently made the news as the first area in Michigan where an EFM essentially rendered all of the elected officials powerless (also a new power), is a “political” township.
On July 13, 1787, the Confederation Congress passed the Northwest Ordinance (“the NWO”). The NWO created a system of government for the Northwest Territory (which became the states listed above). It also specified how the various parts of the Northwest Territory could become states. Earlier legislation, such as the Ordinance of 1784 and the Land Ordinance of 1785, had only said that the territory would someday become states and had described how the federal government would sell the land to private citizens. The Land Ordinance created the pattern along which American public land would be divided and sold until the passage of the Homestead Act in 1862. The Ordinance of 1785 ruled that the western lands north of the Ohio River would be divided by surveyors into a square grid. Because these federal statutes had related subjects and relatively similar names, in later years “Northwest Ordinance” became a sort of shorthand for all of them.
Under the system created for legal descriptions of land – still used today – each survey township measures six by six miles and is subdivided into thirty-six one-mile-square sections. Each section (measuring 640 acres) could then be further divided, usually into half, quarter, eighth, or sixteenth-section lots of 320, 160, 80, or 40 acres. Certain sections had restrictions placed on their sales; for instance, money from the sixteenth section of every township was to be set aside to fund public schools in the township. Many schools today are still located in section sixteen of their respective townships, although a great many of the school sections were sold to raise money for public education. In later States, section 36 of each township was also designated as a “school section”.
The first territorial survey took place in what is now southeastern Ohio, and it measured land that stretched westward from Little Beaver Creek to the Tuscarawas River and southward to the Ohio River. A total of about 91 townships were created (although some of them were fractional and did not contain a full 36 sections), with about 3,276 sections comprising 2,096,640 acres of land ready for development by U.S. farmers. A one quarter-section of land was the amount allocated to each settler. Stemming from this are the idiomatic expressions, “the lower 40″, which is the 40 acres (160,000 m2) on a settler’s land that is lowest in elevation, in the direction towards which water drains toward a stream, and the “back forty”, the portion farthest from the settler’s dwelling.
If a survey township is disincorporated, your deed now describes…nothing.
As noted above, the EFMs are now empowered to tear up ANY contract – not just collective bargaining or other employment contracts. Deeds are contracts if consideration is paid for the land (they are quasi-contracts if the deed is gifting land – one of the few quasi-contractual agreements allowed under law). Mortgages are contracts, as well.
So, once your deed/mortgage contract is useless and/or terminated, they can seize your land. You can’t prove that you own it, because even if you still have the deed/mortgage, the survey plats on which the legal description is based are invalid. So much for an eminent domain claim to at least get paid for the seizure.
It’s probably a violation of federal law – the NWO, as well as the 5th and 14th Amendments (eminent domain), but private citizens have no power to sue to enforce the NWO, and, as noted, how do you prove your eminent domain claim without a valid legal survey of the land? You can’t.
One other thing: disincorporating a township does NOTHING to get rid of the township’s debt, which is what the Republicans claim is the whole point of the law. (It’s not about the budget.) Plus, we already HAVE a means of ridding municipalities of debt they can’t handle – it’s called Chapter 9 bankruptcy! We don’t NEED an EFM law!
reposted with permission from Facebook page.
Anonymous
There are two separate political jurisdictions over there: City of Benton Harbor, and Benton Township. You are confused. It’s the City of Benton Harbor that was taken over by the EFM. Jean Klock Park is owned by the City of Benton Harbor, now in total control of EFM Harris.
There are different units of local government here: cities, villages, townships. Each are governed by a different set of state laws.
I think, not sure though, that the EFM law applies to all forms of local government.
Anonymous
Save: you missed the point of the Note, which was my original writing (thanks for reposting, Nemo). Yes, the EFM law applies to all forms of government, but that’s not the point – it *also* applies to “survey townships” which have nothing to do with government, but with land ownership. Please re-read the comment.
Anonymous
Since the elected officials of Benton Harbor have had most their powers stripped, I would say this becomes a case of taxation without representation, wouldn’t it? In that case, do the people of Benton Harbor have to pay taxes any more?
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_534XMH4CSUKULJW4YUDXZ3UJ3M S Clause
Very few pay any taxes in Benton Harbor. That’s the problem. Most are unemplyed, on public aid and rent where they live. That’s why the city is deep in debt.
Anonymous
Even if that is the case: it is not grounds for a municipality to be stripped of its elected, representative government.
Anonymous
Just who is it that supports Joe Harris? Whirlpool or Gov. Rick Snyder? Will be very interesting when Snyder shows up there next week.
http://www.facebook.com/people/Juli-OMinion/1480605646 Juli OMinion
So sorry, Michigan. You have Snyder, and we here in Florida have Rick Scott. Birds of a feather, destroying the States together,
Anonymous
whats wrong with this harris guy? they have furnitures stores in benton harbor with pillows that are stuffed with feathers and they have lumber yards that have 5 gallon buckets of tar to sell. he better sleep with one eye open just in case people start thinking like the old days remadies!
http://profiles.google.com/adownriverdiva chay hadden
I like your style! I was wondering where I could get supplies for the party!
If tar is too harsh, we could bring some warm honey or wax!
Anonymous
Mr. Harris is correct. Only the citizens of Benton Harbor truly understand how desperately his assistance was needed. Yes, this new EFM law walks an EXTREMELY slippery slope, but in Benton Harbor it was necessary. In a city that has extreme poverty, there is a dirth of leadership. The current mayor and commissioners are/were so inexperienced and uninformed that they made a bad situation worse. We welcome Mr. Harris’ presence and appreciate all the actions he has taken to turn things around. There is finally a glimmer of hope.
Let me state for the record that I am a Democrat. Mr. Harris was appointed by a democratic governor at the request of the democratic city manager that the mayor and commission dismissed suddenly when he began to investigate corruption (they just settled with him out of court two weeks ago for $192,000). So trying to blame this situation on Governor Snyder doesn’t wash.
The commission also brought this on themselves because when Mr. Harris came to town they had an opportunity to sit, talk and learn with him. They chose not to. Instead, they had commission meetings every two week that amounted to nothing more than a three ring circus and did EVERYTHING in their power to thwart advancement and the correction of their fiscal mismanagement. If they truly had the best interesst of their citizens at heart, they would have sat down and learned how to manage a city correctly. If you read the minutes of the city commission meeting, you would laugh yourself silly that these people were charged to mind a box of rocks, let alone a whole city!!!
All of this stink is being raised by outsiders. I understand….really I do. This law is a dangerous thing, but in the case of Benton Harbor IT WAS AND IS NEEDED! If they overturn this and give governance back to the charlatan mayor and joker commissioners, this city is doomed for sure!!! Look at the turnout these “protests” have drawn. Verrrryyy few people and mostly out-of-towners at that! Outsiders, please go home and let Mr. Harris do his job!!!
Anonymous
“This law is a dangerous thing” You said it yourself.
There has to be a better way.
http://profiles.google.com/adownriverdiva chay hadden
Excuse you, but according to the paper, Snyder claimed the honor of sending this jive turkey to town, ok?
And should this city government be as bad as Kwami and company, they can join them in jail, I do believe the people of Michigan know how to handle corruption and lack of funds and anything else coming down the pike, up to and including sellouts like you.
If this wasn’t written by Harris himself, I’d be might surprised. Or by somebody who lives on the other side of the river in St. Joe.
And let me tell you one more thing, what happens to the least of us is done to the rest of us, we stand together, nobody is going to run over the constitutional rights of any city, town or village in this state for any trumped up and invalid charge.
You don’t make a law and then force people into breaking that law so that you can then punish them to suit you!
That’s pure bullshit and nobody with half a brain is going take that lying down.
Just because you think Black people can’t run a city or be trusted with any kind of responsibility doesn’t make it true.
They used to say that Blacks can’t play BASKETBALL or a few other sports.
No, Blacks were inherently unable to first understand the rules of basketball and second were physically incapable of playing basketball.
That was only back in the 50′s, but look at basketball today, or better still ask Detroit Mayor Dave Bing about how well Blacks can play BASKETBALL?
Get off the floor, YOU HAVE BEEN SLAM DUNKED!
Your boy Harris will be in the unemployment line soon enough.
Violate OUR CIVIL RIGHTS?
NOT WITHOUT A BATTLE AND WE DIE IN THE PROCESS.!
http://profiles.google.com/adownriverdiva chay hadden
There is no basis for the alleged budget busting by ANY UNION, ANY WHERE.
IT’S A LIE THAT ALMOST SOUNDS RIGHT, PARTICULARLY WHEN THE FACTS ARE HIDDEN FROM THE PEOPLE.
How can the unions be breaking the budget and be the cause of the financial mess when they have been taking concession for the at least the last 10 yr!?
HOW?
They have already given up 20% pay cuts SEVERAL TIMES IN THE LAST 2 YRS. WE HAVE PAY STUBS TO PROVE IT.
ALREADY FORCED TO TAKE DAYS OFF EVERY MONTH WITHOUT PAY!
LOST MEDICAL, PENSIONS, LAYOFFS, THREATS WEEKLY OF BEING FIRED OR MORE LAYOFFS. WORKERS ARE SO STRESSED, OVERWORKED AND DEPRESSED AND WORRIED, MANY ARE GETTING PHYSICALLY SICK.
SOME SO BAD THEIR HAIR IS FALLING OUT.
THIS IS NO GUESS, IT’S ACTUALLY HAPPENING RIGHT NOW.
How are people supposed to work and do a good job? Court clerks are trying to fill in for those laid off, attempting to do the work of 3 people, EACH AND EVERY DAY. If one clerk is out sick the whole court schedule gets screwed up.
You can’t have court without a bailiff, can’t care for county records without enough clerks. What used to be taken care of in one day, now carries over 2 sometimes 3 days! Probate court was bad enough when they had full staff and enough clerks, it was always standing room only most days.And this is only about the courts, union workers are in every dept of the city and county.
You don’t think they deserve job security, fair pay, sick days or enough people do competently do the jobs that need to be done?
Maybe they all should just walk out and see just HOW much work will get done without them?
Hey! Can you put out a house fire? Or handle a bad traffic accident? How you gonna park downtown if nobody is working the ticket booth?
Schools closed, kids out of school, no truant officers, no control at all. At least teachers keep the kids off the streets all day!
And if you fire everybody, like Reagan did the Air Traffic Controllers, WHO YOU GONNA GET TO REPLACE THEM?
I’m surprised the unions haven’t already sued Harris for libel, slander and defamation of character for blaming them for the financial downfall of all these 175 cities, towns and villages on Snyder’s Hit List.
Think of the field day the lawyer could have? Class action or individual suits.
175 already slated for EFM’s at least 2 towns in every county.
Nothing like planning ahead, eh? Maybe snyder is a secret psychic?
And if this happens in every county in every state, what would they call?
A BLOODLESS COUP D’ETAT OR TAKEOVER AND DEMOCRACY IS GONE FOREVER.
Anonymous
somebody stole 3 million from a park fund…several reasons these officials needed to be removed but this way is wrong…