Top Stories

The Michigan Messenger going forward

By Staff Report | 11.16.11

I am writing today to announce the closure of the Michigan Messenger. After four years of operation in Michigan, the board of the American Independent News Network, has decided to shift publication of its news into a single site, The American Independent at Americanindependent.com. This is part of a shift in strategy, towards new forms [...]

Colorado-based abstinence program provided false and misleading information to Michigan students

HIV-AIDS-small
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.16.11

An abstinence-only presentation provided to numerous school districts in Calhoun and Eaton Counties in October of this year provided false and misleading information to students about HIV, experts allege.

Class action lawsuit filed against MERS over unpaid taxes

foreclosure
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.15.11

Two county registers of deeds filed a class action lawsuit Monday on behalf of Michigan’s 83 counties alleging that the Mortgage Electronic Registration Services owes millions of dollars in property title transfer taxes.

Schuette fights important mercury regulations

epa_logo
By Eartha Jane Melzer | 11.14.11

Despite evidence of the impact of mercury on children and public health, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette last month joined with 24 other state attorneys general in filing a lawsuit to scuttle new EPA regulations that would reduce mercury emissions from power plants.

Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons
Photo courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Republican ultrasound bill puts new restrictions on abortion

Michigan only latest state for such a bill
By Eartha Jane Melzer | 04.25.11 | 8:22 am

State Senator David Robertson (R-Grand Blanc Twp.) has introduced a bill that would require doctors to offer keepsake ultrasound photos to women who are seeking abortions.

The bill requires that doctors perform an ultrasound, offer a description of the ultrasound image, an opportunity to listen to the heartbeat of the embryo or fetus, and a hard copy of the image.

All of this is to be done at least two hours before the abortion procedure and women would be required to sign a statement acknowledging that these offers had been made.

Robertson did not return a call to talk about the bill, but both those who support the bill and those who oppose it agree that its intent is to dissuade women from having abortions.

A similar bill has been introduced in the House.

“We are all for maximum information being given to any woman seeking an abortion, or any other major operation, for that matter,“ said James Muffett, president of Citizens for Traditional Values which supports the legislation. “It seems quite suspect that abortion providers do not already do this. Maybe they know that there really is a living baby in the womb and if the mother saw that, she might change her mind.”

It is already common practice for abortion providers to use ultrasound to date pregnancies and to rule out ectopic pregnancy.

Alexa Kolbi-Molinas, staff attorney at ACLU Reproductive Freedom Project said that the new requirements proposed in the Robertson bill are designed to shame, humiliate and punish women who seek abortions.

The ACLU has been following efforts to enact new requirements for ultrasound use across the nation and Kolbi-Molinas said that while the proposed Michigan law requires doctors to offer detailed ultrasound information, in some states the proposed laws seem to force women to watch and listen to ultrasound presentations.

“Any women who wants to look at the screen should be able to,” she said. “But what we are seeing is that women are being forced to sit there … Some laws are not even clear that she is allowed to put her fingers in her ears.”

Being pressured to view an ultrasound could be traumatic.

“There is no exception for a woman who has been raped or a woman who actually had a wanted pregnancy and learns that there is something wrong with the fetus that makes it unviable,“ she said. It seems wrong to make a woman look and listen to a description under those circumstances, she said. “It’s hard to say that these laws are about helping women when you look at what they would really do.”

“This bill does nothing to improve health care,” said Sarah Scranton, executive director of Planned Parenthood Advocates of Michigan. “It is clearly just another bill to reduce access to abortion.”

“Since the beginning of the year we’ve seen nearly 20 anti-choice bills introduced in the House and Senate and some have already moved through committee.”

Scranton said that Planned Parenthood expects that bills to restrict access to abortion and birth control will move through the legislature once the budget is finalized.

“If lawmakers were really concerned about reducing the need for abortion they would fund family planning and give women the tools to avoid pregnancy,” she said. “Instead, the state House and Senate Department of Community Health subcommittees have both approved budgets that completely eliminate all state funding for pregnancy prevention services.”

Comments

  • Anonymous

    Another case with the ‘big and powerful repug” men imposing their will on women.

  • Anonymous

    Barefoot and pregnant ,that’s how they want us. Abortion rights are about freedom.for women from the men who wish to keep us powerless.

  • Anonymous

    What I want to know are, where are they finding these incredibly ignorant women who DON’T realize that an abortion involves a fetus until they see it on a screen? The Blue Lagoon?

    Women get it, when they go in to get an abortion. They know what they’re doing. It’s not some lark they do for funsies. It’s a tough choice they make because maybe they can’t offer that child a life, or maybe that child would significantly impair their ability to provide for other children. Punishing women who are already facing a hideous choice is just cruelty for the sake of cruelty.

    You know what might really decrease the rate of abortions? Free daycare, healthcare, food, and other supports. It may take a village to raise a child; for a lot of women, even an extra set of hands would be enough. But apparently we’d rather spend the money on requiring that they be made to feel bad while aborting the child the village isn’t willing to support.

    • Anonymous

      i couldn’t have said it better myself.

  • Anonymous

    Life begins at conception, ends at birth. Republicans claim to be pro-life, really? They are pro-death penalty, pro-war, pro cutting funds to the needy.. How hypocritical… The supreme court has already ruled abortions are legal. Lets move on and focus on the issues at hand. A huge deficit, lack of jobs, crappy roads, etc etc. . .

    • Anonymous

      Big power grab happing now, the Republicans want it their way. Period.

  • http://profiles.google.com/one4progress Doris VanHouse

    Thought these buffoons said they were for reduced government intrusion and less regulations?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Laurel-Zanardelli/100000779757443 Laurel Zanardelli

    If men were the one’s who got pregnant, believe me, abortions would be free and available everywhere. I’m really tired of people who don’t know me, know what’s going on in my life or the circumstances of the situation, trying to impose THEIR morals, THEIR relgion, and THEIR laws on me.

  • http://americanlibertarian.wordpress.com/ TerranceH

    Such a horrible thing for women to be confronted with the truth…

    Why don’t you damn socialists just admit that you do not want to discourage abortion? You people always say that, but your actions speak much differently.

    Laurel,

    You’re an idiot. Every law is someone’s morality. The question is not “Should we legislate morality,” but rather, “Whose morality should be legislate?”

    And what the hell does religion have to do with anything?

    What? What’s that you say? Nothing? You’re just using a common anti-life talking point? Oh, O.K. then.

    Idiots.

    • Auracle

      Why don’t you damn men just admit that you do not want to discourage the control and disenfranchisement of women? You people always say that, but your actions speak much differently.

    • http://twitter.com/Sabertooth1980 Anthony Troglia

      You’re retarded. For one, what right do you have to say what happens to another persons’ body?
      What right do you have to show a woman who is already emotionally conflicted about what she wants to do?
      There are instances were Abortion is a good thing. If the mothers’ health is at risk, if it pregnancy is a product of rape or even of incest. And yes. Even if it is an unwanted pregnancy.
      There are nearly 7 BILLION humans on this planet. We need some form of population control.
      The only smart question you have asked is “Whose Morality should we legislate?”
      Morality isn’t the issue here.
      And religion is brought up because people who are of a religious nature tend to be the ones who keep pushing these kind of bills.
      Oh, look at that, you’re taking the fact that they can’t reply to your post as you are typing it as silence.
      By the way. Nice job poisoning the well with your “anti-life” rhetoric.

      Seriously. Fuck You.

    • Anonymous

      TerranceH sez: “You damn socialists” WTF? I’d be willing to bet real money you don’t have a clue as to what socialism actually is beyond the blatherings of right wing hate radio ala Limbaugh, Beck & Hannity. Remember what Mark Twain said, “Better keep silent and be thought a fool than open your mouth and remove all doubt.”

      Putz.

    • http://profiles.google.com/adownriverdiva chay hadden

      Unless these so-called laws force men to be in the same room and be forced against their will to endure the same treatment, IT’S SEXUAL DISCRIMINATION.
      ONLY WOMEN CAN GET PREGNANT, THIS RULE IS ONLY FOR AND ABOUT WOMEN, BUT WOMEN CAN’T MAKE THEMSELVES PREGNANT, IT TAKES A MAN, THEREFORE THERE HAS TO BE EQUAL TREATMENT UNDER THE LAW OR IT’S DISCRIMINATORY.
      The scans belong to the woman, it’s her choice what to do with it, if she refuses to look at it how are they going to force her to view it?
      She doesn’t need a scan to get an abortion, it’s purpose is to determine the age of the fetus, but it’s not the only way.
      They have no right to sit in session and decide what women can or can’t do without bothering to ask or allow the women any input.
      WE ARE NOT CHATTEL, HELD IN BONDAGE BY MEN.
      WE DON’T NEED LAWS MADE FOR US TO APPEASE THE MORAL VIEWS OF OTHERS, ESPECIALLY MEN! ONLY THE FATHER OF THE BABY HAS A SAY! NO ONE ELSE BUT THE PEOPLE THAT MADE THAT BABY HAVE AN OBLIGATION OR ANY KIND OF MORAL RESPONSIBILITY.
      AND IF THEY DECIDE TO TERMINATE THAT IS STILL ONLY THEIR DECISION!
      IN VIEW OF THE CONCERTED EFFORTS THE REPUBLICANS HAVE MADE OVER THE YEARS SINCE THE PASSING OF ROE vs WADE TO DESTROY AND ELIMINATE ANY SAFETY NET, PROGRAM, BENEFIT, HELP, ADOPTION OR PROVISION FOR WOMEN, BABIES AND FAMILIES OUTSIDE OF THE REPUBLICAN ENCLAVE, REPUBLICANS ARE THE LAST PEOPLE ON EARTH TO BE ALLOWED ANY SAY IN ANY MATTER NOT AFFECTING THEIR OWN PERSONAL, WELL PROVIDED FOR, FAMILIES!
      IN OTHER WORDS GET OUT OF OUR LIVES, CAUSE WE ALREADY KNOW FOR CERTAIN THAT NOT A DIME OF YOUR PRECIOUS TAX MONEY HAS EVER BEEN USED FOR ONE ABORTION.
      YOU PEOPLE DON’T PAY TAXES, WE DO! SO WE SHOULD MAKE THE RULES CONCERNING OUR LIVES!
      YOU OVERBEARING, SELF-RIGHTEOUS, LAMENTABLE, TWO-FACED HYPOCRITES.
      THE ONLY TIME YOU APPROVE OF ABORTIONS IF IT’S TO COVER UP YOUR OWN SCREWING AROUND AND BABY SLIP UPS.
      When that happens you people call it a D & C.
      It’s true, and you know it, been that way for years. But you forgot about the nurses and doctors who had to help you have your approved of cover up abortions.

  • Anonymous

    Well i had to think what i would say here so i’ll try to express what im feeling so here i go God says its alive and the Ten comandments say thou shall not kill and if you think he is imposing his will on you what will you say when you need him? He will turn away from those who hate him and when you stand at the gates of heaven will he know you if he dose ask yourself what dose he know of me? Ask for forgivness and it will be given you but if you think evil is good you shall have your reward!!!!!

    • Anonymous

      keep YOUR cross and mr. christ out of MY vagina, MY ovaries, and MY uterus.

      • Anonymous

        This is not my choice but yours Jesus said they will be judged by the confesion of there Mouth and you are making your’s clear that you would profer to be his enemy but i tell you the Truth He loves you and Died for you and wants nothing more than to be apart of your life i hope you can learn to love We all love you and we can help in your time of need. God Bless you !!!!

    • Anonymous

      Thanks.

    • http://twitter.com/Sabertooth1980 Anthony Troglia

      I would like evidence that this god fellow actually exists please. Testable, demonstrable, repeatable, empirical evidence please.
      Next I would like evidence that this false dilemma you are putting before me is actually real please.
      And lastly, stop with the threats. It makes you look like a fucktard.

    • Anonymous

      I don’t think anyone goes in for an abortion thinking it is “good”. There’s really nothing about it that would be remotely pleasant or easy. For the women who choose that route, however, it may be better than the alternative, for them and their families.

      A lot of women go into it questioning how it fits into their faith, and asking for guidance and comfort from their church and their God. I’m certain many of them feel like God does have an understanding of the difficulties they face. But regardless, that is between them and God. It’s not for man to judge and punish an act we have determined to be legal.

  • Anonymous

    Hey there liberality i agree it is not a easy decision!! people make choices everyday that God dose not agree with including me but this one i think involves a life so it is a little more important there are a million ways to stop from getting pregnant in the first place ( No sex ,Historectomy,birth controle,also there is adoption, exc) We are all verry intelligent i think this could be avoided just like wearing a seat belt to prevent your own death in a car crash!! Anthony if you seek Him you will find Him i will pray for you but you need to let go of your anger to see the truth!!!

  • Anonymous

    This is all i will say on this issue i support it and will call my congress man in support of it and i will fight for what i beleive in!!!!!! good luck to you all and God Bless America and you!!!!!!!!!!

    • http://profiles.google.com/adownriverdiva chay hadden

      You’re free to do that, as long as you agree with them, and I will fight for what I know to be true. I DON’T NEED SOME POLITICIAN TELLING ME WHAT IS MORAL AND WHAT AIN’T!
      LET THEM KEEP THEIR OWN WOMEN UNDER CONTROL AND IN THEIR PLACE!
      Get real and face the truth, these same hypocrites vote for wars against innocents, send your sons and daughters to kill those they proclaim to be your enemy, but hasn’t done a thing against you, spend billions daily of your dollars to kill Muslim babies and mothers, strip you of needed funds for your daily life and well being to fight countries they are in competition with in the market place but tell you it’s to preserve your freedom! Wars for oil in foreign lands while there is plenty stored in our own closed down wells.
      Let them decide how many people should be on allowed to live on Earth at one meeting, and go to another to decide how many abortions are killing off their future warriors and wage slaves and who will replace those lost to abortions.
      GO ASK THEM “WHERE DO YOU FIT IN?”
      OR ARE YOU JUST ANOTHER HUMAN RESOURCE TO BE USED AND THROWN AWAY LIKE TISSUE!
      I DARE ANY OF YOU WHO SUPPORT THAT BILL TO ASK YOUR POLITICIAN THAT QUESTION, “WHY DO THEY CARE ABOUT POOR WOMEN GETTING ABORTIONS?”

  • http://www.facebook.com/renard.prather Renard Prather

    Why stop there, why not make a law that any man who fathers a child out of wedlock should be given a vasectomy immediately!

  • Anonymous

    This is sadistic. When will old Republican white men leave women’s health decisions to women, their doctors, and their families?

  • Anonymous

    What annoys the hell out of me about the whole anti-abortion crowd is they’re fetishizing fetuses and subjugating women in one fell swoop. There’s no other explanation for it, because none of these GOTP pols give a damn about that fetus once it shoots out of the old birth canal. Then the kid is on its own. How else to explain their lack of support for infant/child health, nutrition, and education programs? It’s despicable and extremely hypocritical.

  • Anonymous

    One question, after reading about everything going on in Lansing, who voted for these crazy men? Elections have consequences.

  • http://profiles.google.com/adownriverdiva chay hadden

    WHY MUS THEY PLAY GOD DAILY?
    DO THEY GET SOME KIND OF “HIGH” OR THRILL FROM THIS?
    YOU CAN’T BE AGAINST ABORTIONS AND FOR WARS!
    WHO FIGHTS THE WARS?
    THE BABIES WHO GREW UP POOR AND HUNGRY AND DESPERATE FOR A JOB, AN EDUCATION, A HOME AND A LIFE FOR THEIR OWN FAMILIES.
    SO THEY ENLIST IN THE ARMY OR NAVY BECAUSE THAT’S THE ONLY WORK MANY OF THEM CAN GET!
    HOW MANY WERE SPARED BEING ABORTED, BUT NOW BEING SENT OFF TO DIE ON ALIEN SOIL FIGHTING THE NEEDLESS WARS OF THOSE WHO SAVED THEM!
    TWISTED IRONY, ISN’T IT?
    WHAT’S REALLY TWISTED?
    The fact that nearly every man and woman sent to Iraq and Afghanistan have to serve multiple tours of duty, even when scheduled to be sent home, time after time, until after the 4th or 5th time they mentally unable or so damaged they are useless in battle.
    And when they get home they get treated like dirt by the VA.
    Yes stop aborting future soldiers before there is a shortage and it becomes necessary to send all those GW bush types into battle.

  • Anonymous

    The government needs to stop this emotional blackmail bs.. As if deciding to terminate a pregnancy isn’t a big enough decision. I’m so sick of this attitude that suggests that women everywhere are running around cavalierly getting abortions for craps and giggles because we’re all selfish bitches who hate the unborn and Jesus, or that we’re too stupid or easily swayed to realize what a fetus looks like – as if we need a photo to remind us.

    It is in my body, and I if am not in a position to feel like I can adequately take care of a child, and I am already in the clinic ready to undergo the procedure, then I will have it done, it’s my decision and a carefully weighed decision with many factors, however there are other women who possibly be swayed by the images and the heartbeat, and I can say that just allows more children in Michigan to go without adequate support, health care, education, emotional and will be put in MiChild and the mother will be on “welfare” until that child turns 18 all based on a decision his/her mother made based on emotion. Welfare was designed to be a temporary help to those in need, I live in Michigan and I can clearly tell you many people that live in this state are lifers on the program and many are on the system fraudulently.

    These people need to crawl out of our collective vaginas and find some new things to rage about, because this is ridiculous. Michigan already has that 24 hour waiting period, plus the state mandated propaganda that women are supposed to read before having the procedure.

    As far as Michigan’s abortion laws go, let’s redirect our energy and thoughts with something that a positive directive, like welfare fraud, the state’s budget, children’s educations, public services such as fire departments, police, town consolidating because we have a major budget crisis here and the lifers on welfare, state aid, and those who are fraudulently using those types of aid, are not helping our situation by breeding more.

  • Anonymous

    I’d also like to know this man’s personal interest with abortion. Why take this stance on this issue?