A Michigan Public Service Commission investigation has determined that DTE Energy was not responsible for the fires that burned 81 homes in Detroit during a Sept. 7 windstorm.
The commission held hearings and conducted an investigation after Detroit residents claimed that the utility company failed to respond calls about overgrown vegetation on lines and illegal hook-ups.
In a report released this month the Commission stated:
· Data demonstrate that Detroit Edison completed proper maintenance and reliability improvements.
· On a per-mile basis over the last five years, Detroit Edison spent approximately 26 percent more on tree-trimming/vegetation management in the city of Detroit than the rest of the system. The MPSC staff observed that improper tree trimming was not a factor in the wire-downs that occurred during the storm.
· Staff did not observe any overwhelming issue with the age of the distribution system in Detroit or the affected area, and found that Detroit Edison spent 14.5 percent more on operations and maintenance in the city of Detroit than on the rest of the system.
In a story for the Michigan Citizen, Marcus Wright reports that some Detroiters feel that MPSC has not provided proper oversight of DTE’s vegetation removal.
“During the Sept. 29 public meeting convened after the fires, MPSC said it would investigate claims of overgrown vegetation on wires,” [Utility activist and Detroit resident] Edith Lee-Payne said. “If it had done so, it would have seen extreme vegetation still on wires … and if it looked today it would see vegetation still on the wires.”
Payne said she sent the commission a video of vegetation hanging on wires last year, but it was ignored by the commission.
“The problem is the commission allows DTE to self regulate,” Lee-Payne said.
The Detroit Fire Department has not yet determined why there were so many fires during the windstorm.
Mayor Dave Bing ordered demolition of the burnt houses within two days of the fire, drawing criticisms at the time from some retired firefighters and community members that the hasty demolition amounted to obstruction of justice.