Top Stories

The Michigan Messenger going forward

By Staff Report | 11.16.11

I am writing today to announce the closure of the Michigan Messenger. After four years of operation in Michigan, the board of the American Independent News Network, has decided to shift publication of its news into a single site, The American Independent at Americanindependent.com. This is part of a shift in strategy, towards new forms [...]

Colorado-based abstinence program provided false and misleading information to Michigan students

HIV-AIDS-small
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.16.11

An abstinence-only presentation provided to numerous school districts in Calhoun and Eaton Counties in October of this year provided false and misleading information to students about HIV, experts allege.

Class action lawsuit filed against MERS over unpaid taxes

foreclosure
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.15.11

Two county registers of deeds filed a class action lawsuit Monday on behalf of Michigan’s 83 counties alleging that the Mortgage Electronic Registration Services owes millions of dollars in property title transfer taxes.

Schuette fights important mercury regulations

epa_logo
By Eartha Jane Melzer | 11.14.11

Despite evidence of the impact of mercury on children and public health, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette last month joined with 24 other state attorneys general in filing a lawsuit to scuttle new EPA regulations that would reduce mercury emissions from power plants.

Michigan transgender teen challenging high school’s refusal to let him be homecoming king

By Todd A. Heywood | 09.28.10 | 11:55 am

A Mona Shores teenager is crying foul after administrators in the West Michigan school invalidated the vote of his peers in a race for homecoming king.

Oakleigh Reed says he wanted to run for the position because he was as qualified as any other person running. School officials defend their decision, reports NBC 25:

Assistant Superintendent Todd Geerlings said the issue is simple: The ballots gave two choices, vote for a boy for king and a girl for queen.

In a report Monday night, WOOD TV 8 in Grand Rapids interviewed a school official who claims the district did not violate any nondiscrimination rules by refusing to crown Reed as King. The station first broke the story Sunday night.

But Reed says the school has acknowledge his transition to male by addressing him with male pronouns, allowing him to wear the male uniform for band and the male graduation gown.

The ACLU of Michigan’s Jay Kaplan had this to say on the issue in an e-mail to Michigan Messenger:

We are aware of the situation here and it raises issues as to whether this student is being treated differently by the school district because of his gender identity. Gender identity is not a protected category under our state civil rights laws, nor does Muskegon include it in its anti-discrimination policy. However, discrimination against transgender persons because of gender stereotyping has been found in some cases to be actionable sex or gender discrimination. At any rate, there have been other school districts that have permitted transgender students to serve as Homecoming King or Queen in accordance with the student’s gender identity and expression. It’s disappointing that the Mona Shores School District has decided to take the opposite approach, particularly where previously it has shown sensitivity towards this student, regarding how he is referred to in school (and his ability to wear a male robe at graduation). We hope the district will reconsider its decision.

Julie Nemecek, a nationally recognized transgender activist who was fired from the conservative Christian Spring Arbor University after she began her transition, also weighed in on the controversy in an e-mail to Messenger:

The point that the school is missing is that gender is determined by the brain and not the genitals. Established case law in the 6th Circuit Court of Appeals says that when the Civil Rights Law of 1964 says “sex” it also means gender. The student was discriminated against for being who he is no less than if the school had said the prom king or queen had to be white.

The ACLU has reached out to Reed and requested permission to write a letter to the school district on his behalf, WOOD TV 8 reports. Reed is reportedly considering accepting the offer.

Comments

  • maggie1962

    I vote for leave the teen alone!!!! I am the mom two teens. They would also vote the same way. It's hard enoungh bing different, but for all of you who believe in god this is how he/she made him. So just step up and except it. It really is not nice to be a mean person!!

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FKOBKZYNUJRU46PVFFKERQYK3Y Pat

      Your comment makes no sense in regards to this article. Did you read it? No one is being mean to this girl that wants to be a king. As far as gender being decided by the brain and not the genitalia, are you kidding me? Does that mean that my dog that has a penis is actually female because it squats when it pees rather than lifting its leg?

      • http://twitter.com/olga__nyc Olga NYC

        I’m sorry, but are you seriously comparing your dog’s peeing to gender identity?!?!

        I am a straight, natural born female, and I am still disgusted by the lack of respect and the complete disregard for common scientific knowledge your comment exhibits. I can only imagine how this poor transgender boy must feel if he is ever surrounded by people like you.

      • GloriaV

        You, Pat, are a jerk. How DARE you compare your stupid dog with a person.

        • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FKOBKZYNUJRU46PVFFKERQYK3Y Pat

          I am not trying to start any name calling or “trolling”. Maybe you are right, and it is not fair to say that my male dog is female. My initial response to Maggie was in hopes that others whom read the article would exhibit some level of skill in regards to reading comprehension. The rest, however, was directed to the statement made by Nemecek in the article that compared a girl wanting to be king, to a person of a race other than white wanting to be king. Absolutely absurd! If the student body wanted to recognize this persons popularity, why not vote them prom queen?

          Furthermore, in an age of political correctness, in a country based on democracy, maybe a heirarchy at prom is a bit archaic. Lets start a movement to vote for Prom President, and Prom First Person.

          • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FKOBKZYNUJRU46PVFFKERQYK3Y Pat

            And another thing GloriaV…My dog is not stupid.

      • Mykell

        Did you read the article? The boy identifies as a boy, his classmates want him to be king, and the school administration is being mean to him.

        • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FKOBKZYNUJRU46PVFFKERQYK3Y Pat

          The school system is refusing to give a girl the title of king. That is not being mean or intolerant. “Prom President” could be held by either, as well as voting two Prom Queens. How did her name get on the ballot for Prom “King” to begin with? Besides, there is nothing “poor” or sad bout this person. This person is obviously a strong individual who has the full support of their peers. This person is making a stand for their rights as a human being and understands that there are opposing arguements. Future generations may benefit from this individuals fight, or maybe not. I don't think she should be King, but I don't have a problem with how HE wants to live HIS life. Also Mykell, explaining every detail of each comment made is exasperating but, my comment to “Maggie”, whom has since retreated, was in respect to her full comment. She “votes for everyone to leave the teen alone”. This “teen” doesn't want to be left alone. This “teen” has an agenda! Fight on! Make waves! That is more than a lot of people these days that blindly accept what they are told as fact. Fight Apathy!!!

    • Coolhand1958

      This is NOT how God made her. She is having a sex change.

      • Shadow23

        I doubt God made people as dumb as most of his followers but yet you're still allowed to be who you are. If this kid feels they're a male in a females body. Who gives you the right, arrogance or intelligence to decide what God wanted. Assuming the theory that God exists, the egotistical out look of his followers are kind of entertaining to the fact that you all think so low of him, that you can decide what he has made or hasn't made.

        Oh, before you decide to use the Bible or any other religious documents to try and prove your point. After all the times it's been “translated” and reprinted I wouldn't count on them being that accurate.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_BGFKAFIFJ6J66GQLCAAKM6T7MQ Jonathan

        God also made people with no arms, mesothelioma, or Cystic Fibrosis. I don't see you objecting to people getting operations to fix how God made *them*

  • http://twitter.com/tww135 Tom Williams

    I can't believe the kids at that HS would tarnish their image by voting for this person, unless the guys are so ugly that a female surgically changed to male should win!!!

    • ASB01

      Perhaps the kids at the HS believe more in promoting tolerance for others than tarnishing their image.

      • Mykell

        They didn't tarnish their image in the first place :)

        • ASB01

          Totally agree. :)

    • Zaxx

      Wow thats total bullshit. Its about whats on the inside not an image.

  • maggie1962

    Its a genetic birth defect on the inside. So she made herself right on the outside.

  • bodiddlydoes

    made herself right- she was made right (you yourself used the pronoun identifier “her”). But lets be objective here- If someone 'feels' like a male on the 'outside' and it 'scientifically' female in all ways physiological/ biological, then she is a female. We are not talking about a person born with both geitalia here- this is someone who is surgically changing their sex on the outside – NOT naturally, but by force. Inside, she will always be female- this in not currently changable.

    This represents psychosis, and how. But, regardless of how I may look at the matter, this person has the right to choose- end of discussion. Conversely, society has the right to ostricize/exclude her for her choice if it deems such to be outside of societal norms. Which currently, it is.

    • http://twitter.com/widdershins_cat Katie B

      Extensive scientific research shows that the brain structures of transgender individuals resemble those of the gender with which they identify, regardless of genital configuration or chromosomal configuration (which is itself sometimes not as clear-cut as you would imagine). Furthermore, that brains of one gender react really, really badly to the other physical sex's sex hormones – when a hormonally female person has the brain of a male person, that person is transsexual (likewise vice-versa).

  • CSTONE55

    If this PERSON is who the student body voted for -then so be it!

    The students are accepting this person as male-have recocognized their own tolerance and acceptance-who are we to say they (the student body) is wrong or cannot have their way-which they legally voted for.

    Again someone is trying to take away our rights as voters!

  • Anonymous

    Gender is not limited to male or female. Its a scientific fact. Look it up. People are born everyday with a set of male, female, or both primary sex organs. There are animals in the natural kingdom who change there primary sex organs throughout there life (Clown Fish). Also transsexulaity is considered a real medical issue. Notjust here in America in the year 2010 but through out the world and throughout history. Once again do your research and you will see thats true. For those of you reading this who are lucky enough to have the same gender Identity (thats what you brain tells you what your are, and your primary sex organs (genitals) match, try to imagine what it would be like to have to walk talk act and were the clothing of your opposite sex and you will begin to understand how a transgender person might feel.