About a week ago the Holland Board of Public Works announced that it would sue the state of Michigan for taking so long to decide on an air permit for a planned coal plant expansion. Today the DNRE may have preempted that lawsuit by announcing that it is rejecting the request to build a new 78 megawatt boiler at that DeYoung Plant in Holland.
The decision marks the second time this year that state regulators have rejected air permits for coal plants deemed unnecessary by the Michigan Public Service Commission.
In July the Michigan Public Service Commission found that the HBPW’s projection of future electricity demand was overly optimistic and that the utility had failed to consider the impact of increased efficiency measures. The MPSC also stated that the Holland utility’s power needs could also be met through a combined cycle natural gas plant or renewable options.
“In assessing the HBPW submittal, and the findings of the MPSC, the DNRE is persuaded by the MPSC report,“ G. Vinson Hellwig, chief of the DNRE’s Air Quality Division wrote in the denial letter issued today. “HBPW has not adequately demonstrated that the proposed boiler is necessary to meet its projected capacity requirements.”