Top Stories

The Michigan Messenger going forward

By Staff Report | 11.16.11

I am writing today to announce the closure of the Michigan Messenger. After four years of operation in Michigan, the board of the American Independent News Network, has decided to shift publication of its news into a single site, The American Independent at Americanindependent.com. This is part of a shift in strategy, towards new forms [...]

Colorado-based abstinence program provided false and misleading information to Michigan students

HIV-AIDS-small
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.16.11

An abstinence-only presentation provided to numerous school districts in Calhoun and Eaton Counties in October of this year provided false and misleading information to students about HIV, experts allege.

Class action lawsuit filed against MERS over unpaid taxes

foreclosure
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.15.11

Two county registers of deeds filed a class action lawsuit Monday on behalf of Michigan’s 83 counties alleging that the Mortgage Electronic Registration Services owes millions of dollars in property title transfer taxes.

Schuette fights important mercury regulations

epa_logo
By Eartha Jane Melzer | 11.14.11

Despite evidence of the impact of mercury on children and public health, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette last month joined with 24 other state attorneys general in filing a lawsuit to scuttle new EPA regulations that would reduce mercury emissions from power plants.

Hard times drive more Michiganders to fish for food

By Eartha Jane Melzer | 07.27.09 | 10:47 am

Despite health department warnings that many Michigan fish are contaminated with mercury, PCBs, dioxin and other chemicals, more people are fishing in order to put food on their tables, according to this Detroit Free Press story, which quotes a Dept. of Natural Resources spokeswoman as saying, “It’s a great way to feed a family.”

Reporter L.L. Brasier interviews out-of-work electrician, Kirk Miller, who is relying on fish from Lake St. Clair for protein and finds that he is part of a growing trend.

Miller is among a growing number of anglers in Michigan. Although the number of boat registrations has dropped, likely because of the cost of hauling, gasoline and boat slips, more people are throwing a line in the water than ever before. The state sold 703,695 fishing licenses in 2007 — around the time the state began to slip into a deep recession. That number has jumped by 54,234 this year to 757,929, the highest in the state’s history.

State officials say many people may be like Miller: loading up the tackle box and heading for the lake or river as a way to cut grocery costs and have cheap fun as well.

Unfortunately, this story does not mention the Department of Community Health fish consumption advisory which urges people to learn about contaminants in fish before eating them, and warns that children and pre-menopausal women be especially careful about eating fish.

The health department warns:

Many chemicals end up in lakes, rivers, oceans and in some of the fish we eat. Eating polluted fish won’t make you sick right away. But the chemicals found in fish can build up in your body and make you very sick later on. Some of these chemicals can harm your immune system, reproductive system, brain functions, or increase your risk of cancer. Children and babies that get too much of these chemicals may develop physical, mental or behavioral problems that they would not have had otherwise.

Comments

  • Matthew_Arnold

    I credit my mom's second husband with ruining me on fish when I was growing up in Wisconsin. An itinerant poet and worker of odd jobs, he fished for much of his food in Lake Michigan, oblivious to the warnings about PCBs and heavy metals posted on the piers. Every day he was down there, from March through November, whatever the weather. I didn't like him and so, I reasoned, I didn't like fish either. My mom left him after awhile and ten or fifteen years later, I learned he was dying of stomach cancer in Milwaukee. I've since made my peace with fish — but not from Lake Michigan, thanks very much. I can see how someone a little less lucky than I, lacking access to non-line-caught, low-mercury, sustainably-caught or farmed fish, but having a lake, a fishing pole and a rumbling stomach, would read those signs a little differently. It's hard to worry about PCBs giving you cancer twenty years down the line when you're young, healthy, hungry and broke.

    • michaelgowell

      “Line caught” is far preferable to trawled (caught by a dragged net) fish. Line caught fish come aboard live and whole – not crushed and dead. Dragging destroys unmwanted bycatch and the bottom habitat. It has been compared to harvesting squirrels by uprooting the oaks and shaking them.

      • Matthew_Arnold

        Whoops. There you go. Everything I know about fishing I learned from reading the labels on cans of tuna at Food Hole. Guess I meant “Line caught” then.

      • mirandawest

        Don't talk about trawl fishing when all you know is from predjudiced old Eco videos. Trawl fishing today is highly regulated, caught with specialized nets, in clean deep ocean waters, with fish observers on every boat. Try finding out instead of spouting false info.

        • michaelgowell

          I know from holding a Maine netting license – I use small stationary gill nets checked each tide – and from 40 years of residence in a fishing port. Let me remind you of a fairly recent ad campaign by a manufacturer of dragged “rock hopper” nets – “With these the fish have no place to hide.” That's the inherent assumption of dragging – take everything and devil take the hindmost . Dragging helped crash the North Atlantic fisheries. Dragging trawl nets is like fishing for trout with hand grenades. Dragging is stupid old technology – check out the northern European hook fishery to see where things are heading.

          And your “observer on every boat”…what BS. The fisheries guys can't even manage to keep one guy on duty at each of the landing docks, let alone one on each boat.

          • markymarc

            Come on Mirandawest!! Are you going to let michaelgowell talk to you like that!!? He's attacking your credibility by saying that he's got MORE credibility than you! Oh, Snap! You need to be a real man (or woman as the case may be) and give him (or her as the case may be) the “what for”.

            if there's one thing that I can't stand, that's when some online news article commenter tries to tell me he knows more than me. And, by golly, i would be MAN enough (or again woman enough as the case may be) to defend my integrity, my intelligence, my credibility, my honor against such heinous attacks.

            I mean REALLY. Is there no decency among men (or women as the case may be) anymore?

            Talk about CHILDISH behavior!

  • justwatchin

    Maybe here in michigan we are out of work and I don't know what you do when you are out of work , I fish as I did not have time when I had a job. Hell I don't even like eating fish period but I sure like catching then.

  • Jeff68

    I live in northern Indiana, as close to Michigan as you can get. I grew up on trot-line caught fish, and my extended family STILL eats about 20% of their diet from the rivers. I'm healthy in my 50's and my aunts and uncles haven't died yet…well into their 70's and 80's. I still enjoy the fish fries when we get together.

    I got a BS in Biology in the 70's and have really been entertained by the 'fear this' media and their cutesy stories about poisonous fish caught and eaten. I personally will not fear the fish from my local streams unless the advisories quote the species tested and the place from which they were taken, by river and by location on that river. Many, many of the written advisories are just passed on, recycled news stories taken out of context and clearly designed to scare us.

    I'm NOT saying be ignorant, but rather, be INFORMED. Look for the specifics. Heed the specific and credibly supported articles and learn to spot the recycled bull-oney. If an article appears that warns about fish and it does NOT include “caught exactly from THIS stretch of THAT river, by name,” AND it does NOT include “exacltly WHAT lab did the test and WHAT toxins in EXACTLY THESE concentrations,” then it is likely bull-oney. You don't have to know everything to avoid being driven before the bull-oneyistic cattle drivers. Just ask yourself if you'd pay money for the information being peddled.

    Many people will state that we the public don't have the capacity to understand the specifics. Maybe that is so, but I maintain that far, far more DO have that capacity, and even those who do not are not necessarily too ignorant to spot a scam when they see it coming.

    One last thing to bear in mind. A fish in the skillet, even if poisonous in the long term, won't necessarily kill you as fast as starvation or the illnesses of malnutrition that come to the poorly nourished.

  • imagebarer

    Since Obama is planning to cut Medicare by $35B, this might be a good thing. With all the baby boomers soon joining Medicare and Obama cutting it, they will have to start euthanising our seniors. Instead of giving them the drugs to do that, or instead of keeping them from getting health care, Obama can feed them the contaminated fish. It probably would be cheaper than euthanasia and less painful for those they want to get off of Medicare.

  • N1P
  • markymarc

    Come on Mirandawest!! Are you going to let michaelgowell talk to you like that!!? He's attacking your credibility by saying that he's got MORE credibility than you! Oh, Snap! You need to be a real man (or woman as the case may be) and give him (or her as the case may be) the “what for”.

    if there's one thing that I can't stand, that's when some online news article commenter tries to tell me he knows more than me. And, by golly, i would be MAN enough (or again woman enough as the case may be) to defend my integrity, my intelligence, my credibility, my honor against such heinous attacks.

    I mean REALLY. Is there no decency among men (or women as the case may be) anymore?

    Talk about CHILDISH behavior!

  • markymarc

    Come on Mirandawest!! Are you going to let michaelgowell talk to you like that!!? He's attacking your credibility by saying that he's got MORE credibility than you! Oh, Snap! You need to be a real man (or woman as the case may be) and give him (or her as the case may be) the “what for”.

    if there's one thing that I can't stand, that's when some online news article commenter tries to tell me he knows more than me. And, by golly, i would be MAN enough (or again woman enough as the case may be) to defend my integrity, my intelligence, my credibility, my honor against such heinous attacks.

    I mean REALLY. Is there no decency among men (or women as the case may be) anymore?

    Talk about CHILDISH behavior!

Categories & Tags: Economy| Environment/Energy| |