The Grand Traverse County village of Fife Lake and a local church have reached a settlement in a federal lawsuit against the town for treating religious groups differently from other community organizations in allowing such groups to use a government-owned municipal building. A consent decree (PDF) has been issued by the court.
The Forest Area Bible Church had filed the suit because Fife Lake had a policy that allowed most non-profit community groups to use the municipal building free of charge but required the church to pay a rental fee to use the same facility. This is something that the courts have long forbidden. In a series of rulings beginning with Lamb’s Chapel v Center Moriches School District in 1993, the Supreme Court has said that if a government entity allows community groups to use public facilities they must treat religious and non-religious groups in an equal manner.
Under the consent decree agreed to by both sides, the church will be reimbursed for 18 months of rental fees and all non-profit groups will now be charged $20 to rent the facility. The village will also pay $1,765 in court costs incurred by the church.