Top Stories

The Michigan Messenger going forward

By Staff Report | 11.16.11

I am writing today to announce the closure of the Michigan Messenger. After four years of operation in Michigan, the board of the American Independent News Network, has decided to shift publication of its news into a single site, The American Independent at Americanindependent.com. This is part of a shift in strategy, towards new forms [...]

Colorado-based abstinence program provided false and misleading information to Michigan students

HIV-AIDS-small
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.16.11

An abstinence-only presentation provided to numerous school districts in Calhoun and Eaton Counties in October of this year provided false and misleading information to students about HIV, experts allege.

Class action lawsuit filed against MERS over unpaid taxes

foreclosure
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.15.11

Two county registers of deeds filed a class action lawsuit Monday on behalf of Michigan’s 83 counties alleging that the Mortgage Electronic Registration Services owes millions of dollars in property title transfer taxes.

Schuette fights important mercury regulations

epa_logo
By Eartha Jane Melzer | 11.14.11

Despite evidence of the impact of mercury on children and public health, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette last month joined with 24 other state attorneys general in filing a lawsuit to scuttle new EPA regulations that would reduce mercury emissions from power plants.

Dow-sponsored Walleye Fest to donate contaminated fish to the poor

By Eartha Jane Melzer | 04.22.09 | 12:54 am

warningsignUpdated, April 23, 8:17 p.m.

Despite advisories that warn people to avoid contact with river sediments and consuming locally caught fish, thousands are expected to participate this weekend in a Dow Chemical-sponsored walleye festival along the Tittabawassee and Saginaw rivers, where the watershed has been contaminated with harmful dioxin and other toxic substances.

And just as the Michigan Department of Community Health is warning that children and pre-menopausal women should mostly avoid eating river fish including walleye because of contamination from polychlorinated biphenyls and dioxin, organizers of the festival say they plan to donate walleye fillets to a local food bank.

“Dow and MidMichigan Health [the local hospital system] have always been the biggest sponsors of the festival,” said Steve Doyle, spokesman for the Freeland Lions Club which has organized the festival for 24 years.

This year’s event features a Special Olympics hot dog cook-out, a teen dance and battle of the bands, a rummage sale and beer tent. But the centerpiece of the festival is the walleye tournament — a competition to see who can catch the largest fish from the river.

Doyle said that the people fishing for walleye are aware of the state fish advisories. “The fishermen all know about the advisories ’cause they are posted when you buy a permit,” he said.

“We don’t serve any walleye caught in river,” he said, adding that the fish served during the Friday evening fish fry is “probably pollock.” Doyle estimates that 80 percent of the Walleye Fest competitors will keep and use the fish they catch.

“Other people donate them to food banks,” he said. “If people don’t want the fish we will filet the fish and donate them to different food organizations that want them.”

Dioxin remediation work three miles downstream from Freeland in Saginaw Township’s West Michigan Park will not impact the river-wide festival, Doyle said.

It is breeding season for walleye. The fish are swimming from Saginaw Bay, up the Saginaw and Tittabawassee rivers, through a zone that some insist should be listed as a Superfund site. In 2007 the highest level of dioxin contamination ever measured by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency was found in the Saginaw River prompting emergency clean up. Other dioxin remediation projects are ongoing. The entire span of the river used for the walleye festival is known to be contaminated with dioxin from chemical manufacturing operations at Dow Chemical’s Midland plant.

Kory Groetsch, toxicologist with the state Department of Community Health said that larger fish are likely to contain higher concentrations of chemicals.

“Science at this point is not able to say [that] if you ate this one fish it is going to cause X amount of cancer,” he said. This is because everyone has different history of past exposure, and different genetic and health issues.”

The department is wary of events like Walleye Fest. “We don’t endorse fish festivals.” Groetsch said. “We are trying to get the public information about consuming fish at a rate that is going to be protective.”

The department recommends children under 15 and pre-menopausal women eat no walleye larger than 18 inches and one meal per month from walleye under 18 inches.

This could make finding a safe walleye difficult.

According to Joseph Bohr, an aquatic biologist with the DEQ’s water bureau, the legal size for walleye is 15 inches. And since the walleye are currently headed up river to spawn those caught during Walleye Festival are likely to be larger, full grown adults.

More information about Michigan fish advisories is available at the website for the Michigan Department of Community Health.

UPDATE, April 23, 8:17 p.m.: State warns that Walleye Fest participants aren’t being properly warned of toxic dangers

Comments

  • lenheinz1

    The rhetoric concerning the dioxin issue in our area has become tiring and inconsequential as far as the vast majority of citizens in our area are concerned.

    We now have another anti-corporate biased diatribe hitting the web links concerning the Walleye Festival held yearly in our community. The Freeland Lions Club has held the annual Walleye festival for 24 years and it has grown to become the premier event in our area. We are extremely proud of our accomplishments and the help we are able to provide to our community through the funds raised during our festival.

    The age old arguments concerning the safety of eating fish caught in our area have been brought up again and again. Even though the Journal of the American Medical Association documents the fact that the health benefits of eating fish far out weigh any concerns of contamination we still live with the stigma. Everyone is aware of the fish advisories and the cautions put forth by the Michigan Department of Community Health. Every fisherman I have ever talked to uses the advisories to keep janitors employed by throwing them in the trash the minute they are received.

    It continues to be hard to fathom why individuals would continue to disparage the image of our communities and state given the horrible situation we find ourselves in. NO ONE HAS EVER BEEN HARMED BY DIOXIN IN OUR AREA. Prove otherwise and maybe you will have some legitimacy. There are no widespread high levels of dioxin in our population and we have studies to prove it. What is very troublesome is the lack of individual thought within our governmental regulatory bodies such as the EPA and MDEQ. What a breath of fresh air it would be if an intelligent person within one of these agencies would actually break ranks and confirm the compelling evidence, we have in hand, that dioxin is not a threat to our population.

    While it has become apparent that our elected officials, our local newspapers, and community groups want this issue to go away we still have the stubborn faction that thrives on the dark side of data. Their cup is always half empty instead of half full. As a proud Freeland Lion Club member I will continue to try my best to provide help to those less fortunate in our area. Our festival gives us that leverage and we continue to grow despite the subversive efforts such as this little article in the Michigan Messenger. What does that tell you? We would never do anything as a result of our efforts that would put the public health in jeopardy. To have a sneaky little article such as this insinuate that we knowingly are doing this is sick perverted journalism at its worst.

    Please take your inconsequential efforts and corporate hatemongering somewhere else where real problems exist. The money being wasted on this issue has reached the point where people are disgusted knowing that it could have been spent on so many other worthwhile projects. We do have real problems in our society and environment. This is not one of them, but is symptomatic of the misguided mindset that causes wastefulness and serves only to massage the ego of a few extremists.

  • upnorthMI

    It is unfortunate that the Freeland Lions Club has gotten tangled up in a controversy regarding a community service and event they provide. At the same time, lets not completely ignore intelligent thought when discussing the dioxin pollution that exists in the Saginaw and Tittabawassee rivers. While lenheinz1 claims that this is all a big conspiracy, I would urge you to consider the findings of such medical organizations such as The American Diabetes Association, The American Journal of Epidemiology, and many others who have studies the effects of dioxin contaminates in our environment for decades. They post conclusive studies of human contamination effects ranging from Hodgkin's disease, non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma, Leukemia, Diabetes, chronic respiratory and cardiovascular diseases, as well as increased occurences of rectal and lung cancer and other birth defects, to name a few. I would say to call such effects of dioxin as “inconsequetial and tiring” is an insult,
    Now, are these millions of medical professional worldwide all part of this anticorporate hate mongering conspiracy? I think that their interests, as well as mine, are more concerned with the human health impacts to our communities and families.
    I don't believe that this was intended to disparage a community or organization, merely an attempt to bring attention to a serious public health issue, even if it was done with an attention-grabbing and shocking title.
    I believe that the Lions organizations around the world, do wonderful and generous things for our communities, as I'm sure yours does also. But also try to keep an open mind about how such an event could have unintentional and harmful consequences.

  • rick11789

    This would be quite a story if it were true, but it isn;t. The Freeland Lioins club have never donated fish from this tournament to any food bank or anyone for that matter. It is funny that the Michigan DNR considers the fishery in the Saginaw Bay watershed to be a great success story while the Michigan Department of Health grinds whole fish trying to keep the numbers high enough to still include walleye in thier advisories. People I know filet their fish and remove the mud viens. Even with this deception our walleyey test the same as farm raised salmon you can buy in your local store.Eartha come see us this weekend, and see how a great community enjoys the outdoors.

  • rickpetes

    lenheinz1, Are a member of the local chamber of commerce?

  • dogwoman

    I do not know enough about local studies to draw conclusions. However, the way lenheinz_1 speaks about how it is safe, nobody has gotten sick, and its just a bunch of corporate hate-mongering subversive extremists wasting valuable resources sounds much like the citizens of a little place called Libby, Montana. For years whenever environmentalists and government agencies tried to bring to light the health risks caused by the local mining industry that the community was completely dependent on economically, they were referred to in similar ways. It always seemed that the community was provided with a series of corporate sponsored tests “proving” the inaccuracy of charges of environmental dangers that may have resulted from corporate activities. That is, until more than 200 folks died and over 1000 were diagnosed with lung disease. The company then abandoned the town leaving them not only economically bankrupt but sick and dying. .Something to think about..

  • Inform

    Rick,
    I didn't see them state Lion's club were donating fish. If your walleye tests similar to farm-raised salmon, that is a very bad thing not a good thing, as farm-raised salmon are highly contaminated. in comparison with fresh water salmon. I wouldn't feed a dog that stuff.

    It is disgraceful that a body of water that Dow wants categorized as a Superfund is the site where people are donating fish from it to the poor. Why isn't Dow serving their execs and themselves that fish? Even more disturbing that MidMichigan Health would condone such.

  • Inform

    Lenheinz,
    Please provide your peer reviewed references with your assertions regarding dioxin contamination and public health effects. Also, if you've got some stats from people leaving Dow and retiring to other locales, dying there and their death certificates, I'd appreciate those. How many are diagnosed with nonhodkins lymphoma that grew up here and worked at Dow?

    (I'm very well read on peer reviewed scientific literature on dioxin, so look forward to your providing me with additional references substantiating your claims)

    My nonscientific opinion is that there is no doubt that testosterone in area males has been adversely affected as most seem to lack cajones in addressing group think and looking at peer reviewed scientific literature (you are aware it is an endocrine disruptor, right).

  • http://www.checkdepressionsymptoms.com/ Depression Symptoms

    Donating contaminated fish is against professional ethics I guess. This should not be practiced.

  • http://www.checkdepressionsymptoms.com/ Depression Symptoms

    Donating contaminated fish is against professional ethics I guess. This should not be practiced.