UPDATED: To reflect the passage of the final FISA bill by the Senate later Wednesday afternoon.
Senate bills intended to strip telecommunications corporations of immunity from lawsuits for assisting the U.S. government on illegally spying on everyday Americans by offering officials total access to private phone calls and e-mails were all defeated this afternoon. The failed amendments would have re-written previously passed legislation that granted immunity, which President George W. Bush had lobbied for strongly since the beginning of the year. The original FISA bill, with immunity attached, was later passed 69-28.
Continued -Some observers have written that the vote on the three amendments was manufactured by Democrats to give presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama a chance to vote against immunity after initially voting for the previous “compromise” bill that granted immunity.
That vote was widely criticized by Obama’s liberal base as a sell-out to the very corporate special interests that he so often attacked in campaign speeches while seeking the nomination.
The strategy of giving Obama the opportunity to vote no on immunity before he voted yes for it, failed miserably. Obama was the target of more venom today from progressives, civil libertarians and Americans of all stripes when he later voted yes on today’s final vote for the original bill, which included immunity. The defeat of the amendments and the original bill’s ultimate passage this afternoon is being assailed by observers of constitutional law. Michigan’s two Democratic senators, Carl Levin and Debbie Stabenow, both voted against FISA.
A breakdown of today’s final vote on FISA can be seen here.
You’ll notice that, including Obama, 22 Democrats — if you count Joe Lieberman as a Dem — voted for FISA. Presumptive GOP presidential nominee John McCain did not vote.
Not one Republican joined Levin, Stabenow and the remaining Democrats in voting no on the bill that offers immunity to the likes of AT&T for their illegal cooperation with the Bush administration.
Christy Hardin Smith at Firedoglake covered it live here. Comments from readers and her graphic are especially illuminating/apt.