Top Stories

The Michigan Messenger going forward

By Staff Report | 11.16.11

I am writing today to announce the closure of the Michigan Messenger. After four years of operation in Michigan, the board of the American Independent News Network, has decided to shift publication of its news into a single site, The American Independent at Americanindependent.com. This is part of a shift in strategy, towards new forms [...]

Colorado-based abstinence program provided false and misleading information to Michigan students

HIV-AIDS-small
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.16.11

An abstinence-only presentation provided to numerous school districts in Calhoun and Eaton Counties in October of this year provided false and misleading information to students about HIV, experts allege.

Class action lawsuit filed against MERS over unpaid taxes

foreclosure
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.15.11

Two county registers of deeds filed a class action lawsuit Monday on behalf of Michigan’s 83 counties alleging that the Mortgage Electronic Registration Services owes millions of dollars in property title transfer taxes.

Schuette fights important mercury regulations

epa_logo
By Eartha Jane Melzer | 11.14.11

Despite evidence of the impact of mercury on children and public health, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette last month joined with 24 other state attorneys general in filing a lawsuit to scuttle new EPA regulations that would reduce mercury emissions from power plants.

“There’s no school.”

By Minehaha Forman | 07.07.08 | 9:20 am

For some neighborhoods in Detroit, public education’s history

Out in my backyard in Detroit, where pear trees hang heavy with growing fruit and the buzz of honey bees fills the warm air, I stand over a wheelbarrow full of mulch, chatting with my neighbor about the plight of Detroit Public Schools. A mother of four, Lori Weertz has chosen not to send her children to Detroit Public Schools because the quality of education there is abysmal. But there’s one other reason: there’s no school to go to. Really. Even if she wanted to get her kids into public school, she said the one in the area — a walkable distance — was closed years ago.

Ferry Elementary School, the school that served her neighborhood, was closed in 2005. Since then, the only school option for the children in the area are charter schools, some miles away.

If she sent her kids there, she would be paying for the bus to come and pick them up and bring them home, a fee among others that she can’t afford. So she has decided to home school her three youngest boys.

Continued -She told me about Ferry Elementary down the street, and how it has been accumulating litter and has been a target of vandalism. Since its closure three years ago, the large, three-story building has not been leased out nor is it serving any purpose.

So when I asked her opinion about the expected drop in enrollment to below 100,000 this fall that would trigger a flood of charter schools and cripple public education, she looked at me with a knowing smile and said, “Minni, in this neighborhood there’s already no public education.”

Since 2005, 67 schools in Detroit have closed due to plummeting enrollment numbers. Perhaps the damage has already been done.

Maybe it was the matter-of fact way she said it, but in all the news I’d heard over the past weeks about DPS, nothing hit quite as hard as hearing it from her, a parent, first hand.

I decided to pay the abandoned Ferry school a visit to see what the city was doing with the vacant building. Was this space truly not being utilized, or were they at least trying to do something productive with the old building? The embedded video shares what I found.

Comments

  • Tony Collings

    Depressing These pictures, and your good commentary, tell a depressing story that needs to be told. As a society we should be outraged.

  • Ben Place

    Detroit has no schools at all? I don’t think so… I’m not saying DPS is peachy, but your piece fails some quick reality checks:

    A quick Google found Campbell Elementary, which Google maps says is 1.3 miles away from Ferry Elementary.

    There is no part of Detroit that is 20 miles away from Ferry Elementary in a straight line. 20 miles north out Mound Rd. is Utica; 20 miles east on I-94 is Mt Clemens; 20 miles west is Metro Airport; 20 miles south is Lake Erie, I think; 20 miles south on I-75 is Brownstown Twp.

    There aren’t any elementary schools in Detroit? Google says that’s not true.

    I enjoy your stories, I’m glad you’re paying some attention to my city, I know you’re new here, and I know everything feels really far from everything else here, but really! 20 miles?

  • Minehaha Forman

    To clarify: Thanks, Ben, for your helpful comment. The figures I used were from person in my neighborhood who was trying to explain the public school problem. I will be sure to correct them.

    However, I think the main problem is transport, and moving the kids around to the different schools. What was once a walkable trip now is a drive, and many people don’t have cars. Also, no free school bus services this particular neighborhood.

      Granted, of course there are still plenty of elementary schools in Detroit:
    (http://www.schooldig…).
      It’s just a matter of accessibility and quality of the education. Of the five+ kids on my block, all of them attend charter schools or are home-schooled.

    One mom on my street said she didn’t know where Campbell academy was. There are so many  charter schools available, the public city operated ones are buried and the education qulaity there, I imagine, is not stellar. The schools that most kids go to in the area:  Detroit Merit Charter Academy, Chrysler Academy, Detroit Academy for Arts and Sciences … all charter schools.

    I truly appreciate your comment. I even called Campbell elementary to see what services they provide to neighborhoods that used Ferry elementary. A teacher answered and said there was no secretary or principal there today, and that I should “call back tomorrow” and hung up. I suppose I will call back tomorrow.

  • Tony Collings

    Depressing These pictures, and your good commentary, tell a depressing story that needs to be told. As a society we should be outraged.

  • LoRayne Apo-Joynt

    State or Federal law violations? I wonder if there aren't guarantees that ensure students have access to public education?

    Bothers me greatly that Detroit's literacy rate has been as low as 40%, yet massive holes like this exist in the education system.

  • Ben Place

    Detroit has no schools at all? I don't think so… I'm not saying DPS is peachy, but your piece fails some quick reality checks:

    A quick Google found Campbell Elementary, which Google maps says is 1.3 miles away from Ferry Elementary.

    There is no part of Detroit that is 20 miles away from Ferry Elementary in a straight line. 20 miles north out Mound Rd. is Utica; 20 miles east on I-94 is Mt Clemens; 20 miles west is Metro Airport; 20 miles south is Lake Erie, I think; 20 miles south on I-75 is Brownstown Twp.

    There aren't any elementary schools in Detroit? Google says that's not true.

    I enjoy your stories, I'm glad you're paying some attention to my city, I know you're new here, and I know everything feels really far from everything else here, but really! 20 miles?

  • Minehaha Forman

    To clarify: Thanks, Ben, for your helpful comment. The figures I used were from person in my neighborhood who was trying to explain the public school problem. I will be sure to correct them.

    However, I think the main problem is transport, and moving the kids around to the different schools. What was once a walkable trip now is a drive, and many people don't have cars. Also, no free school bus services this particular neighborhood.

      Granted, of course there are still plenty of elementary schools in Detroit:

    (http://www.schooldig…).
      It's just a matter of accessibility and quality of the education. Of the five+ kids on my block, all of them attend charter schools or are home-schooled.

    One mom on my street said she didn't know where Campbell academy was. There are so many  charter schools available, the public city operated ones are buried and the education qulaity there, I imagine, is not stellar. The schools that most kids go to in the area:  Detroit Merit Charter Academy, Chrysler Academy, Detroit Academy for Arts and Sciences … all charter schools.

    I truly appreciate your comment. I even called Campbell elementary to see what services they provide to neighborhoods that used Ferry elementary. A teacher answered and said there was no secretary or principal there today, and that I should “call back tomorrow” and hung up. I suppose I will call back tomorrow.

  • LoRayne Apo-Joynt

    State or Federal law violations? I wonder if there aren’t guarantees that ensure students have access to public education?

    Bothers me greatly that Detroit’s literacy rate has been as low as 40%, yet massive holes like this exist in the education system.