Top Stories

The Michigan Messenger going forward

By Staff Report | 11.16.11

I am writing today to announce the closure of the Michigan Messenger. After four years of operation in Michigan, the board of the American Independent News Network, has decided to shift publication of its news into a single site, The American Independent at Americanindependent.com. This is part of a shift in strategy, towards new forms [...]

Colorado-based abstinence program provided false and misleading information to Michigan students

HIV-AIDS-small
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.16.11

An abstinence-only presentation provided to numerous school districts in Calhoun and Eaton Counties in October of this year provided false and misleading information to students about HIV, experts allege.

Class action lawsuit filed against MERS over unpaid taxes

foreclosure
By Todd A. Heywood | 11.15.11

Two county registers of deeds filed a class action lawsuit Monday on behalf of Michigan’s 83 counties alleging that the Mortgage Electronic Registration Services owes millions of dollars in property title transfer taxes.

Schuette fights important mercury regulations

epa_logo
By Eartha Jane Melzer | 11.14.11

Despite evidence of the impact of mercury on children and public health, Michigan Attorney General Bill Schuette last month joined with 24 other state attorneys general in filing a lawsuit to scuttle new EPA regulations that would reduce mercury emissions from power plants.

Detroit journal: Something is dreadfully wrong

By Minehaha Forman | 06.10.08 | 2:24 pm

[COMMENTARY] When I was first asked to cover Detroit for Michigan Messenger, I got a little uneasy. I had just moved to the city from Rochester, Michigan and was concerned that I was not qualified to be an informant on a place I didn’t know anything about. Over the past couple of months, I’ve added commentary about Detroit, and about race, but there’s a sore spot that I have been avoiding.

Something is dreadfully wrong in some of these neighborhoods.

Sometimes, what I see is so bad it’s shocking. I almost don’t want to publish this, because it will make the city seem scary and frighten people off or make current residents think I’m putting down their home city. That is certainly not my intention. I chose to move to Detroit and I don’t plan on leaving anytime soon — that speaks for itself. But as much as I’m growing to love this city, I can’t sit here in denial. I want to write about the positive things going on and all the hope that’s still alive but can’t write about hope until it’s clear what I’m hoping for, or what we need to fix and move away from.

I hate to say negative things about any place where people are living and fighting to make things better. But if these stories can reach the right ears, maybe something will change. I choose to stay. Some people don’t have a choice. And as I broadcast these tales from Detroit across the vast Internet, I’m keeping them in mind. I want to flag down help from the air, from the water, from the ground, but I’m starting to wonder: Maybe I am the help. Maybe you are, too. I just need to keep telling stories and taking pictures and writing down the bones.

Continued -

On the drive home, I see some unsettling sights. I see a house on fire, all ablaze in the night, a house with all the windows knocked out, abandoned. I get the sense of utter abandonment, a feeling that I am in some forgotten land of which we dare not speak.

I wake up in the morning to a sound like thunder, and the whole house is shaking, I hear glass breaking and my body gets tense: Is it an earthquake? No, a house just blew up down the street, there are chunks of floorboards falling from the sky. The force of the explosion throws three children and two adults all the way to the other side of the street. They are unconscious. It’s a gas explosion, and I wonder frantically if they are alive. The sound of local news choppers circling above like vultures makes me wonder where those choppers were when the family couldn’t afford to pay the gas bill and manipulated the pipes to stay warm this winter. DTE reported after the explosion that gas had been cut off to that house months before, and it had an illegal hookup. According to the Detroit News, a four-year old was left in critical condition, but coverage of the story was short, and my neighbors said they didn’t know the family enough to contact them for a follow-up.

But I stayed living in this neighborhood after the explosion because I feel at home here. Here’s a huge garden in the back yard, it’s usually very quiet and peaceful, and I like living here over the suburbs because there is no pretension. I feel like I can be myself, eccentric and creative, and it’s my own little world. In short, I feel free from the rigid constraints of society here. I guess it reminds of a place I’ve been homesick for: Belize. It’s a hard feeling to describe.

It’s April and I am driving to the highway and I see kids are playing in the streets with worn clothing, broken fragments of wood for toys. In his backyard, a boy hits a cracking basketball with a baseball bat, over and over. I don’t think he has access to a baseball.

It’s a hot spring day; chopped fire hydrants are spraying cool water on overheated children who don’t have access to luxuries like a hose, or air conditioning. They’re running through the water and laughing. A man holding a drink in a brown paper bag stands on the corner looking on.

I see people, old and young, women and men stumbling outside the liquor stores at 1:30 a.m. and I know something’s not right. An uneasy feeling creeps across my skin at the sight of a man in the darkness walking two pit bulls toward my car. I slow down so as not to hit him, he passes, and then I realize he’s just trying to get somewhere, too. I’m not sure if I should be ashamed or relieved.

On my left, there’s a house with a clothesline in the backyard. All year round, there are socks, sheets, shirts, hanging there, drying. I am reminded of my childhood in Belize when the concept of a washer and dryer was luxurious.

I see a house that has 12 people living in it. Everyday there is someone on that porch. I wonder how they all fit into that house, I am reminded, again of Belize were crammed households were very common.

The shells of old abandoned houses and overgrown storefronts remind me of the urban decay seen in the movie “I Am Legend”. These are symptoms of a mass evacuation. Sometimes I struggle with understanding how it got like this: How did this happen? Factories closed, and the race riots scared off all the masses. That’s what they say. But how do we bring them back?

It’s a sunny morning in may and I see a man walking, and as he walks he is vomiting on himself; it’s running down the front of his worn gray T-shirt and he keeps walking, keeps vomiting, until my car overtakes and passes him and he becomes just a figure in the distance.

Maybe in those tales, I’ve just described any city’s life. I hope I am not making a spectacle of those living in poverty because this is a very serious problem. It’s true I haven’t been to a lot of major U.S. cities, but I have a feeling they’re not all like this. But I also know a lot of these problems are not unique to Detroit. This is a human problem, and poverty is a global issue.

I’m new to Detroit but I’ve been in poverty before: I’m no stranger to the Third World. The only thing is, I’m not in Belize. I’m in the land of the free, the strongest nation in the world, the United States of America.

Comments

  • Eartha Jane Melzer

    thank you Detroit is our state’s biggest city yet we hear very little from its neighborhoods. Any plan to fix Michigan must take Detroit into account. Describing the hard issues in human terms like you do here can help make that happen. Please tell us more. I’d like to know how many people face utility shut-offs and what they are doing to cope.

  • mejamison

    Something is dreadfully wrong all over the nation. I guess I would like to ask the question “did you grow up in a fortress?” because these scenes you describe are not only in Detroit, but in cities all over the nation. You make Detroit look as if this is what it is all about. Have you even bothered going into the better neighborhoods of the city. There are thousands of cities that have dilapidated areas with residents that have given up all hope, and it really doesn’t help them to keep reading all of the negative commentaries from reporters who are eccentric and remain in their own little world. Instead of just reporting about them, why don’t you initiate something that is going to help get them out of their situation, or find some good in all of the bad that would inspire. Yes, Detroit does have some bad areas, but the good areas far outweigh the bad areas, only you have to travel outside of your realm of security to see them. And besides, if everyone that sees what you see decided to do one thing to help, that area would turn around eventually.

    I can’t get out to travel the city so I did what I could that would instill a little hope in maybe someone who has lost hope. I report articles of hope that I have read about where Detroit is being revitalized and appreciated. Although I was not born in Detroit, I have acquired a great love for this great city. The home of Motown and the auto industry; the great city of escape for slaves travelling the underground railway. There are so many good places to visit in Detroit. Please take time to look.

    Please visit http://viewofdetroit…

    Another excellent site for your perusal is http://www.modeldmed…

  • milquetoastpeasant

    Courage In The Face Of Diversity Occasionally I visit Detroit’s clean and safe Woodward corridor and enjoy the art, the entertainment and sports like many other suburbanites from Oakland County, but last year I had the distinct displeasure to venture outside of my comfort zone and ended up in a neighborhood around I-94 and Livernois. I was aghast. The place looked like what I imagine Baghdad looks like outside the Green Zone or the Ninth Ward after Katrina. I knew things were bad in parts of Detroit, but this neighborhood just looked forgotten and the few remaining residents I saw, understandably demoralized. Like Minehaha wrote, these are the symptoms of a mass evacuation – of money, of jobs, of education, of resources and of hope which took forty years to get as bad as they did.

    An immediate, massive infusion of transit and infrastructure dollars and maybe high-profile British-style security might broaden the Woodward corridor success to include some of the surrounding neighborhoods but don’t hold your breath. It’s going to take a lot more courage at the local, state and federal level than I’ve seen in this last decade if there is going to be meaningful progress in Detroit. It most likely will have to happen despite our politicians worst efforts – which, it seems, we can always count on.

    Direct contact from residents in the burbs to those in the city could give some moral support in a desperate situation if nothing else. Perhaps a neighborhood buddy system where suburban neighborhood associations with organizational skills are linked up with poverty-stricken neighborhoods in Detroit who may need help organizing their residents. Direct association between the disparate racial and socioeconomic classes, I think, could render some lasting results on both sides.

    Now, If only we can find the courage.

  • ShakespearesIdiot

    Interesting… Interesting idea in regards to the suburban/urban buddy system.  The problem is that the issue is much deeper than economics.  There is also a tremendous divide between the Detroit and its suburbs racially and culturally as well. 

  • Celeste Whiting

    Something is dreadfully wrong Sure, every American city has rich and poor, but the scope of devastation in Detroit stands alone in our region.

    Why isn’t Detroit more like Chicago? Chicago is a thriving regional peer. What’s the difference?

    Several things:
    1. Former “hog butcher to the world,” Chicago is not a one-industry city and has fostered “knowledge-based” business for decades. Financial services, advertising, higher education, law, medicine, fine arts all contribute to economic diversity of that city.

    2. A cultural commitment to higher education. While Chicago Public Schools have suffered as urban schools, the state of Illinois supports gifted and talented programs and mandates daily physical education for K-12. Kids get daily exercise of mind and body. The goal is recognize and cultivate talent as early as possible and to get kids into higher education.  The Chicago metro area is home to many colleges and universities and several national research labs.

    3. Vast public green spaces along the lake front and throughout the metro area provide relief from urban congestion. Chicago’s lakeshore provides public gathering space with beaches, gardens, museums, concert venues, ball fields and more. Vast public green space helps create and sustain cultural identity and a sense of community.

    Is there hope for Detroit? Sure. If people can shake off the legacy of over-dependence on the automotive industry and imagine a better future.

  • joanb

    Great post! I would add that this is happening in other sagging urban districts in the state as well.

    I live in downtown Lansing. Although there are many wonderful things going on here, and I love my house so dearly, if you walk two blocks in any direction the poverty and despair is downright savage.

    Courage is not only wanted, but it’s downright necessary.

    Thanks for the great post.

  • Minehaha Forman

    A human problem Joanb brings up the great point about sagging neighborhoods in other parts of the state. And to leave those pLaces out of the discussion would be irresponsible. There are places in Saginaw, Flint, Pontiac, Lansing… that could tell stories similar to the ones I described in this piece. So that’s more of a reason to have this dialogue continued, and get it out there. Learning what goes on isn’t fun. The truth hurts. The big question is, now that we know, what can be done? Can we trust that policy makers and govt. programs will dig us out, or will there have to be some sort of grassroots movement that does it? We’ve been abandoned by the Auto industry. We can’t sit here and cry for food. How are we as  state gonna create enough jobs to bring back the auto era? Green energy? Sounds good to me.

  • christhefur

    It’s a tough fix There is a myriad of ways to attempt restoration of these forgotten parts of Detroit but, sadly enough, there are far too little residents in the surrounding areas – Detroit, as well – willing to help out with the rebuilding of Michigan’s “lost city.”

    Race and culture play a huge role in the separation of city and suburb. We all know this to be true. Of course, suburbanites LOVE to come down to take part in our celebrations and parades (and occasional after-hours raids), but they’re lack of exposure to actual Detroit residents keeps this divide, well, divided. There is also the unwilling attitude of some of the city’s residents to accept those dissimilar to us, which makes it almost impossible to improve the situation when both sides are reluctant to do so.

    What do we do?

  • Eartha Jane Melzer

    thank you Detroit is our state's biggest city yet we hear very little from its neighborhoods. Any plan to fix Michigan must take Detroit into account. Describing the hard issues in human terms like you do here can help make that happen. Please tell us more. I'd like to know how many people face utility shut-offs and what they are doing to cope.

  • Minehaha Forman

    poverty This is what its like to live in poverty. Some people, when they think “poor” they think oh, I can afford that DVD or new shirt. No. being poor and being in poverty are two different levels. Because I was raised in a situation that would be called poverty here, I am not as shocked when I se sight like this. What shocks me is that it right here in Michigan, just 20 miles north is the second wealthiest county in the U.S. other than Orange County in California. What  was standard in the Third World country of Belize, is poverty here. What confuses me is that this is supposed to be “first world”. Something's not right.

  • mejamison

    Something is dreadfully wrong all over the nation. I guess I would like to ask the question “did you grow up in a fortress?” because these scenes you describe are not only in Detroit, but in cities all over the nation. You make Detroit look as if this is what it is all about. Have you even bothered going into the better neighborhoods of the city. There are thousands of cities that have dilapidated areas with residents that have given up all hope, and it really doesn't help them to keep reading all of the negative commentaries from reporters who are eccentric and remain in their own little world. Instead of just reporting about them, why don't you initiate something that is going to help get them out of their situation, or find some good in all of the bad that would inspire. Yes, Detroit does have some bad areas, but the good areas far outweigh the bad areas, only you have to travel outside of your realm of security to see them. And besides, if everyone that sees what you see decided to do one thing to help, that area would turn around eventually.

    I can't get out to travel the city so I did what I could that would instill a little hope in maybe someone who has lost hope. I report articles of hope that I have read about where Detroit is being revitalized and appreciated. Although I was not born in Detroit, I have acquired a great love for this great city. The home of Motown and the auto industry; the great city of escape for slaves travelling the underground railway. There are so many good places to visit in Detroit. Please take time to look.

    Please visit http://viewofdetroit…

    Another excellent site for your perusal is http://www.modeldmed…

  • Minehaha Forman

    I agree As I said in the commentary, I would like to comment on the nice things that are happening in Detroit.  I have, and will. I said “some neighborhoods.” There are actually a lot of beautiful things happening in Detroit, and I do help out in my community by planting gardens, playing with the children in the neighborhood and contributing positive attitudes about the city. I'm here, I think that says a lot. But some people do live in a fortress, so to speak, and they don't know what goes on in some of these neighborhoods. I was just thinking to myself after I posted this that I need to follow up with some positive stories, because I'd hate for people to get the complete wrong impression.

    Thanks for your comment, you make a great point.

  • Minehaha Forman

    Nicer places I spend a lot of time at Campus Martius, Hart Plaza, the river walk … Downtown, in general, is gorgeous. Eastern Market is fantastic, The Belle Isle Conservatory is wonderful, I am going to visit the lake museum soon, which is also free on Belle Isle. I attend all the festivals, and lots of concerts. Just this weekend the Festival of the Arts went on in Detroit and it was great. I enjoy the CSS art shows, The DIA, The MOCAD, the local restaurants like seldom Blues and Union Street.  I went to Flower Day at Eastern market and reported on that. I do plan on talking about these places, too. If I were to only  feature those places all the time, this site might start looking like Hour Detroit magazine. There are two sides of the story.  I agree: All of it should be out there, the good and the bad.

  • milquetoastpeasant

    Courage In The Face Of Diversity Occasionally I visit Detroit's clean and safe Woodward corridor and enjoy the art, the entertainment and sports like many other suburbanites from Oakland County, but last year I had the distinct displeasure to venture outside of my comfort zone and ended up in a neighborhood around I-94 and Livernois. I was aghast. The place looked like what I imagine Baghdad looks like outside the Green Zone or the Ninth Ward after Katrina. I knew things were bad in parts of Detroit, but this neighborhood just looked forgotten and the few remaining residents I saw, understandably demoralized. Like Minehaha wrote, these are the symptoms of a mass evacuation – of money, of jobs, of education, of resources and of hope which took forty years to get as bad as they did.

    An immediate, massive infusion of transit and infrastructure dollars and maybe high-profile British-style security might broaden the Woodward corridor success to include some of the surrounding neighborhoods but don't hold your breath. It's going to take a lot more courage at the local, state and federal level than I've seen in this last decade if there is going to be meaningful progress in Detroit. It most likely will have to happen despite our politicians worst efforts – which, it seems, we can always count on.

    Direct contact from residents in the burbs to those in the city could give some moral support in a desperate situation if nothing else. Perhaps a neighborhood buddy system where suburban neighborhood associations with organizational skills are linked up with poverty-stricken neighborhoods in Detroit who may need help organizing their residents. Direct association between the disparate racial and socioeconomic classes, I think, could render some lasting results on both sides.

    Now, If only we can find the courage.

  • Minehaha Forman

    Exactly. I think you articulate this point very well. I'm truly not trying to put the city down, or discourage hope with this piece. But ignorance is not bliss, and too many people across the state have NO IDEA what goes on. Thanks for your insight.

  • ShakespearesIdiot

    Interesting… Interesting idea in regards to the suburban/urban buddy system.  The problem is that the issue is much deeper than economics.  There is also a tremendous divide between the Detroit and its suburbs racially and culturally as well. 

  • Celeste Whiting

    Something is dreadfully wrong Sure, every American city has rich and poor, but the scope of devastation in Detroit stands alone in our region.

    Why isn't Detroit more like Chicago? Chicago is a thriving regional peer. What's the difference?

    Several things:

    1. Former “hog butcher to the world,” Chicago is not a one-industry city and has fostered “knowledge-based” business for decades. Financial services, advertising, higher education, law, medicine, fine arts all contribute to economic diversity of that city.

    2. A cultural commitment to higher education. While Chicago Public Schools have suffered as urban schools, the state of Illinois supports gifted and talented programs and mandates daily physical education for K-12. Kids get daily exercise of mind and body. The goal is recognize and cultivate talent as early as possible and to get kids into higher education.  The Chicago metro area is home to many colleges and universities and several national research labs.

    3. Vast public green spaces along the lake front and throughout the metro area provide relief from urban congestion. Chicago's lakeshore provides public gathering space with beaches, gardens, museums, concert venues, ball fields and more. Vast public green space helps create and sustain cultural identity and a sense of community.

    Is there hope for Detroit? Sure. If people can shake off the legacy of over-dependence on the automotive industry and imagine a better future.

  • joanb

    Great post! I would add that this is happening in other sagging urban districts in the state as well.

    I live in downtown Lansing. Although there are many wonderful things going on here, and I love my house so dearly, if you walk two blocks in any direction the poverty and despair is downright savage.

    Courage is not only wanted, but it's downright necessary.

    Thanks for the great post.

  • Minehaha Forman

    A human problem Joanb brings up the great point about sagging neighborhoods in other parts of the state. And to leave those pLaces out of the discussion would be irresponsible. There are places in Saginaw, Flint, Pontiac, Lansing… that could tell stories similar to the ones I described in this piece. So that's more of a reason to have this dialogue continued, and get it out there. Learning what goes on isn't fun. The truth hurts. The big question is, now that we know, what can be done? Can we trust that policy makers and govt. programs will dig us out, or will there have to be some sort of grassroots movement that does it? We've been abandoned by the Auto industry. We can't sit here and cry for food. How are we as  state gonna create enough jobs to bring back the auto era? Green energy? Sounds good to me.

  • christhefur

    It's a tough fix There is a myriad of ways to attempt restoration of these forgotten parts of Detroit but, sadly enough, there are far too little residents in the surrounding areas – Detroit, as well – willing to help out with the rebuilding of Michigan's “lost city.”

    Race and culture play a huge role in the separation of city and suburb. We all know this to be true. Of course, suburbanites LOVE to come down to take part in our celebrations and parades (and occasional after-hours raids), but they're lack of exposure to actual Detroit residents keeps this divide, well, divided. There is also the unwilling attitude of some of the city's residents to accept those dissimilar to us, which makes it almost impossible to improve the situation when both sides are reluctant to do so.

    What do we do?

  • ShakespearesIdiot

    Something is dreadfully wrong all over the nation, especially Detroit. Let me start by saying that there is a need for positive reporting on the city of Detroit.  There are some positive things going on within the city and reporting on these things is noble in that it inspires and encourages hope. I have respect for anyone who wishes to infuse hope into a city so torn, so battered and so demoralized.

    However, I think that when reporting (regardless of your intent) it is important to be fair, objective and factual. And the assertion that “[d]etroit does have some bad areas, but the good areas far outweigh the bad areas” is uninformed, inaccurate and naive. As a native Detroiter, I was shocked to read such a gross mischaracterization–one that blatantly undermines reality. The reality of the city is ugly. It is bitter, harsh and unforgiving.  Understandably, some choose to ignore that reality and favor instead the glaring and robust history of the city or the “better neighborhoods” and the like.

    It is easier to report on (as this article does) the negative aspects of Detroit. But the reason WHY it is easier is because these things represent the true, destitute condition of a forgotten metropolis; the small minority of positivity that exists, frankly, do not.  The pristine and ever-improving downtown, replete with gentrification and bright-eyed ex-suburbanites does not accurately represent the truth of the city. The small neighborhoods such as Sherwood Forest and Rosedale Park which boast a high concentration of Detroit's middle and upper-class black professionals and business owners does not justly portray the city's reality as a whole either. 

    The reality is within the other ninety-plus percent of Detroiters who live in neighborhoods and situations that are desolate and epidemic. They live inside my mother and grandmother who don't live in the “better parts” because they live hand-to-mouth. The fact that you were “not born in Detroit” is overwhelming apparent as is the notion that you “can't get out to travel the city”.  Because if you were, and if you did, you would agree with firm and abiding conviction that something is reprehensibly wrong with Detroit. There may be “thousands of cities that have dilapidated areas with residents that have given up all hope”. But if you compare apples to apples and count every U.S. Major city with a pop. of 500,000 or more, there are only 33.  Of these Detroit has the highest instances of violent crime, poverty, segregation, incarceration, drop-outs and infant mortality just to name a few.

    Detroit is not a microcosm representing a norm of urban areas with a the expected healthy balance of good and bad, rich and poor, black and white.  There is no bell-curve that represents Detroit as a you would expect from a large city.  The city is the poster-child for economic disparity. It is the epitome urban decay. The people are demoralized and the policy makers are seemingly apathetic. That is the reality of Detroit, wholly, objectively and unadulterated.

    “[T]he good areas far outweigh the bad”? To inspire hope and change is one thing, but that statement is unpardonable. It is harmful and offensive. Tell that to the people who live there. If you want to do some “feel-good” reporting, thats fine and admirable, but do so fairly. Don't just dote ostensibly on Detroit's triumphs at the expense of it's reality.  Hope is one thing that that can undoubtedly change the face of the city. Others are education, jobs and unity–with these perhaps the “area would turn around eventually.” In the meantime we must be careful not to mistake realism for pessimism (accusing other's of being in their own world when they report on the world as it presents itself or bend facts to create hope while forsaking truth–because truth, I presume, is what good reporting should be about, pleasant or not, eccentric or not.

  • Minehaha Forman

    Thank You Shakespearsidiot, thanks for your thoughtful response.  I couldn't have said it better myself and I'm thankful for that. In writing this I did face an ethical dilemma, and I understand the connotations of telling sad and bad stories about Detroit, because ultimately PR does a lot for cities. But as I said before, ignorance is not bliss. Once people and policy makers know, they should be compelled to do something.

  • LoRayne Apo-Joynt

    You've described what was wrong in NOLA Many of the same problems afflicted New Orleans, but it had both the blessing and the damnable curse of Katrina to lay bare so many of the problems that were papered and painted over by decades and more of neglect.

    Detroit has been suffering a different kind of hurricane, a slow-moving but ever bit as battering storm that whisks away resources and leaves destruction in its wake.  It's a testament to what happens when a city over-identifies and over-concentrates upon a single industry, which when it likes can pick up and move and leave a husk behind, like a massive corporate locust feasting and fleeing.

    Until Detroit looks at itself as something other than the home of the auto industry and begins to plan out a map to a new and more diverse and sustainable future, it will struggle with its current state.

    And yes, there are other cities like Detroit here, too, Flint and Saginaw being lesser siblings suffering from the same familial disease.

  • Minehaha Forman

    Flint Flint is just as bad if not worse…though I don't know how it could get much worse. But you're right NOLA has the same problems: racial and economic.

      In terms of the auto industry, it's long gone. We're not the motor city anymore and we need to move on.  The only places making money in Detroit seem to be fast food, gas stations, churches, liquor stores, etc.

  • Minehaha Forman

    poverty This is what its like to live in poverty. Some people, when they think “poor” they think oh, I can afford that DVD or new shirt. No. being poor and being in poverty are two different levels. Because I was raised in a situation that would be called poverty here, I am not as shocked when I se sight like this. What shocks me is that it right here in Michigan, just 20 miles north is the second wealthiest county in the U.S. other than Orange County in California. What  was standard in the Third World country of Belize, is poverty here. What confuses me is that this is supposed to be “first world”. Something’s not right.

  • Minehaha Forman

    I agree As I said in the commentary, I would like to comment on the nice things that are happening in Detroit.  I have, and will. I said “some neighborhoods.” There are actually a lot of beautiful things happening in Detroit, and I do help out in my community by planting gardens, playing with the children in the neighborhood and contributing positive attitudes about the city. I’m here, I think that says a lot. But some people do live in a fortress, so to speak, and they don’t know what goes on in some of these neighborhoods. I was just thinking to myself after I posted this that I need to follow up with some positive stories, because I’d hate for people to get the complete wrong impression.

    Thanks for your comment, you make a great point.

  • ShakespearesIdiot

    Something is dreadfully wrong all over the nation, especially Detroit. Let me start by saying that there is a need for positive reporting on the city of Detroit.  There are some positive things going on within the city and reporting on these things is noble in that it inspires and encourages hope. I have respect for anyone who wishes to infuse hope into a city so torn, so battered and so demoralized.

    However, I think that when reporting (regardless of your intent) it is important to be fair, objective and factual. And the assertion that “[d]etroit does have some bad areas, but the good areas far outweigh the bad areas” is uninformed, inaccurate and naive. As a native Detroiter, I was shocked to read such a gross mischaracterization–one that blatantly undermines reality. The reality of the city is ugly. It is bitter, harsh and unforgiving.  Understandably, some choose to ignore that reality and favor instead the glaring and robust history of the city or the “better neighborhoods” and the like.

    It is easier to report on (as this article does) the negative aspects of Detroit. But the reason WHY it is easier is because these things represent the true, destitute condition of a forgotten metropolis; the small minority of positivity that exists, frankly, do not.  The pristine and ever-improving downtown, replete with gentrification and bright-eyed ex-suburbanites does not accurately represent the truth of the city. The small neighborhoods such as Sherwood Forest and Rosedale Park which boast a high concentration of Detroit’s middle and upper-class black professionals and business owners does not justly portray the city’s reality as a whole either. 

    The reality is within the other ninety-plus percent of Detroiters who live in neighborhoods and situations that are desolate and epidemic. They live inside my mother and grandmother who don’t live in the “better parts” because they live hand-to-mouth. The fact that you were “not born in Detroit” is overwhelming apparent as is the notion that you “can’t get out to travel the city”.  Because if you were, and if you did, you would agree with firm and abiding conviction that something is reprehensibly wrong with Detroit. There may be “thousands of cities that have dilapidated areas with residents that have given up all hope”. But if you compare apples to apples and count every U.S. Major city with a pop. of 500,000 or more, there are only 33.  Of these Detroit has the highest instances of violent crime, poverty, segregation, incarceration, drop-outs and infant mortality just to name a few.

    Detroit is not a microcosm representing a norm of urban areas with a the expected healthy balance of good and bad, rich and poor, black and white.  There is no bell-curve that represents Detroit as a you would expect from a large city.  The city is the poster-child for economic disparity. It is the epitome urban decay. The people are demoralized and the policy makers are seemingly apathetic. That is the reality of Detroit, wholly, objectively and unadulterated.

    “[T]he good areas far outweigh the bad”? To inspire hope and change is one thing, but that statement is unpardonable. It is harmful and offensive. Tell that to the people who live there. If you want to do some “feel-good” reporting, thats fine and admirable, but do so fairly. Don’t just dote ostensibly on Detroit’s triumphs at the expense of it’s reality.  Hope is one thing that that can undoubtedly change the face of the city. Others are education, jobs and unity–with these perhaps the “area would turn around eventually.” In the meantime we must be careful not to mistake realism for pessimism (accusing other’s of being in their own world when they report on the world as it presents itself or bend facts to create hope while forsaking truth–because truth, I presume, is what good reporting should be about, pleasant or not, eccentric or not.

  • Minehaha Forman

    Nicer places I spend a lot of time at Campus Martius, Hart Plaza, the river walk … Downtown, in general, is gorgeous. Eastern Market is fantastic, The Belle Isle Conservatory is wonderful, I am going to visit the lake museum soon, which is also free on Belle Isle. I attend all the festivals, and lots of concerts. Just this weekend the Festival of the Arts went on in Detroit and it was great. I enjoy the CSS art shows, The DIA, The MOCAD, the local restaurants like seldom Blues and Union Street.  I went to Flower Day at Eastern market and reported on that. I do plan on talking about these places, too. If I were to only  feature those places all the time, this site might start looking like Hour Detroit magazine. There are two sides of the story.  I agree: All of it should be out there, the good and the bad.

  • Minehaha Forman

    Exactly. I think you articulate this point very well. I’m truly not trying to put the city down, or discourage hope with this piece. But ignorance is not bliss, and too many people across the state have NO IDEA what goes on. Thanks for your insight.

  • Minehaha Forman

    Thank You Shakespearsidiot, thanks for your thoughtful response.  I couldn’t have said it better myself and I’m thankful for that. In writing this I did face an ethical dilemma, and I understand the connotations of telling sad and bad stories about Detroit, because ultimately PR does a lot for cities. But as I said before, ignorance is not bliss. Once people and policy makers know, they should be compelled to do something.

  • LoRayne Apo-Joynt

    You’ve described what was wrong in NOLA Many of the same problems afflicted New Orleans, but it had both the blessing and the damnable curse of Katrina to lay bare so many of the problems that were papered and painted over by decades and more of neglect.

    Detroit has been suffering a different kind of hurricane, a slow-moving but ever bit as battering storm that whisks away resources and leaves destruction in its wake.  It’s a testament to what happens when a city over-identifies and over-concentrates upon a single industry, which when it likes can pick up and move and leave a husk behind, like a massive corporate locust feasting and fleeing.

    Until Detroit looks at itself as something other than the home of the auto industry and begins to plan out a map to a new and more diverse and sustainable future, it will struggle with its current state.

    And yes, there are other cities like Detroit here, too, Flint and Saginaw being lesser siblings suffering from the same familial disease.

  • Minehaha Forman

    Flint Flint is just as bad if not worse…though I don’t know how it could get much worse. But you’re right NOLA has the same problems: racial and economic.

      In terms of the auto industry, it’s long gone. We’re not the motor city anymore and we need to move on.  The only places making money in Detroit seem to be fast food, gas stations, churches, liquor stores, etc.

Categories & Tags: | | | | |